Oops so its me this time eh. I said i find jtyjn a masterpiece. Please reread the " I " . Its my opinion. Not even AR Rahman can change that .
I dont understand the second half of your mail with all the songs and post college things that you mention. Let me break it down for you. If you have seen the movie, jtyjn starts off with the last day of their college. The whole movie is about who gets married to whom rather than careers and romance. Which is like wierd. I mean who wants to get married immediately after college? What i would have wanted or atleast had imagined is how the romance would have blossomed from day one of their college. Have you seen Ishq Vishq the shahid and Amrita rao starrer ? Or even Grease? Thats my idea. Start the movie with the guy getting introduced to Aditi. Then he hurts her somehow and she is pissed. Then get the Aditi song. Not when her cat dies at home like its depicted ! Make the guy a singer in college. Make him a sad version of jtyjn instead of not using it at all. Pappu can be used as a Prom night song. This was my idea. I hope you get it and not compare endlessly with something else. On Thu, Aug 19, 2010 at 1:40 AM, V S Rawat <[email protected]> wrote: > > > On 8/18/2010 6:10 PM India Time, _Gomzy™_ wrote: > > > well said aj. i find jtyjn a masterpiece. > > if jtyjn can be a masterpiece, then Dil Se was could not have been > composed by ARR, that must have been composed by God Himself. > > > > sadly it wasnt well used or > > atleast not used properly. the songs needed a college story and not a > > post college story. > > Oh, Gomzy at conceptualization??? What a new beginning!!! eventually!!!! > > :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) > > Let me test him. > > Please give more examples what type of songs need a college story and > what kind of songs need post college story. > > Humse hai muqabla was a college story, but patti rap and urvashi were > college songs, ok, count premika ne pyar se also a college song, rest > all were post college songs? duniya dilwalo ki's only hello doctor was > college song, rest were post college songs. dil hi dil me's maria was > college song, rest were post college. Jeans' columbus was college, > rest were post college. > > RDB was a post college story, rather well past college, they were 5-6 > years or more past college. how come those college songs ru ba ru, > pathshala merged so well in a post-college story? > > -- > And then, those of us fans who were in college during 90s and liked > the college songs given by ARR at that time, now we are in 40s, > well-past college, how could we like RDB's college songs. > > -- > > What are the elements of a college song? talking about girls, love, > chhutti, books, masti, drinks, picnic, kiddish lyrics or bookish > ideology lyrics? > > -- > Hope Amit Chandran reads Gomzy's post and adds his views on the topic > as he is good at such conceptualizations. > > -- > rawat > > > -- www.gomzyphotography.com
