On Sat, Mar 26, 2022 at 1:52 AM Trigon via agora-business < agora-busin...@agoranomic.org> wrote:
> For another thing, if this were any other report this would not have > been a pointable offense; instead it would have been a harmless CoE. > Officers make mistakes, and there are mechanisms in the rules to account > for human error. This is a double standard that does not do us any good > to uphold. > The fact it isn't a regular report is why I pointed a finger, it was something that actually had an effect on the game. My subpar proposal has to be voted on now, when I thought it wouldn't be because it wasn't pended. Finally, this literally does no harm whatsoever to Agora. In my opinion > crimes exist to chastise someone if something they do harms Agora or > makes it unreasonable to play. I get that this is probably all for the > most-fingers-pointed reward. That is a mechanic of which I have never > been a fan because it goes against that philosophy. > Good thing sets getting repealed could get rid of that. I personally don't know why you wouldn't point a finger at a crime while the option for it to be forgivable exists. If someone accidentally breaks the rules, I think it's in good form to point that out so hopefully the same mistake doesn't happen again and cause someone trouble. I pointed this out because in my head it was very clearly a violation of the rules, given the recent "End of Sets" proposal left the relevant text fresh on my mind. I thought I ought to point out any rule violation, disregarding any rewards it would give me. -- secretsnail, who foolishly thought a forgivable crime wouldn't be that bad to point out
