No. No no no no no. No.
CAN isn't successful either, UNLESS THERE'S A BY ANNOUNCEMENT. The problem ISN'T SHALL and CAN. It's the missing "by announcement". That's what the CFJs say. You've just said "if it says MAY, attempts to do it *are successful*. Even if done in Discussion. Even if done in private. Even if done in your head. In a high-level definition. On Sat, 9 Sep 2017, VJ Rada wrote: > Title: Mother, May I? > AI: 3 > Amend rule 2152 by replacing "MAY: Performing the described action > does not violate the rules." with "MAY: Performing the described > action does not violate the rules and attempts to perform the > described action are successful" > > I submit and pend the above paying 1 shiny. > > > -- > From V.J Rada >
