I like this idea. However, I don’t see a need to adopt it until after or concurrently with the unified system. ---- Publius Scribonius Scholasticus [email protected]
> On Sep 4, 2017, at 6:05 PM, Aris Merchant > <[email protected]> wrote: > > I'm currently working on that unified contracts/orgs/agencies > implementation I was talking about. I want non-player persons to be > able to join contracts, which necessitates some penalty for breaches. > This would also incidentally also fix that thing where G. couldn't be > punished for publishing a false report because e wasn't a player. To > understand what is meant by "persons who play the game" see CFJ 1709. > Of course, most existing punishments are meaningless for non-players, > so I had to come up with something. This proposal adds a new card, > called a Black Card, which, upon activation, prevents the bad sport > from registering or taking any game actions for 30 days. > > Additionally, I feel that with the addition of contracts some > fine/disgorgement mechanism is needed. To this end, I have created a > new card type, know as a Blue Card. A blue card represents a fine in > shines, and whoever awards the card can direct that the money either > go to the player(s) harmed or to Agora. > > > --- > Title: Card Reform and Expansion > Adoption index: 2.0 > Author: Aris > Co-author(s): > > Amend Rule 2426, "Cards", by appending the sentence > > "It is inappropriate to award a card to a non-player person unless the rule > defining the card says otherwise." > > to the paragraph beginning "The types of Card are defined by the rules..." > > > Amend Rule 2478, "Vigilante Justice", to read in full: > > A player CAN by announcement, but subject to the provisions of > this rule, Point eir Finger at a person who plays the game, citing an alleged > violation of the rules by that person. > > When a player Points a Finger, the investigator SHALL > investigate the allegation and, in a timely fashion, SHALL > conclude the investigation by: > > - issuing a Card to the pointed-at person by announcement whose > reason is rooted in the allegation; > > - if e believes that no rules violation occurred or that it > would be ILLEGAL to issue a Card for it, announcing the > Finger Pointing to be Shenanigans. > > The Referee is by default the investigator for all Finger > Pointing. When a Finger, other than the Arbitor's, is Pointed > over an allegation related to the official duties or powers of > the Referee, then the Arbitor CAN, by announcement, take over > the investigation and thereby become the investigator. > > A player CANNOT point a finger more than twice per Agoran week, > or more than once per Agoran week at the same person. > > Amend Rule 2479, "Official Justice", to read in full: > > The Referee CAN, subject to the provisions of this rule, impose > Summary Judgment on a person who plays the game by issuing a card to em by > announcement. > > The Referee CANNOT Point eir Finger or impose Summary Judgment > more than five total times per week, or more than twice per week > at or on the same person. > > As part of the Referee's weekly duties, e SHALL either impose > Summary Judgment on a person or truthfully announce that e > believes that there are no rules violations in the preceding > Agoran week for which a Card has not already been issued. > > > Amend Rule 2474, "Green Cards", to read in full: > > A Green Card is a type of Card that is appropriate for minor, accidental, > and/or inconsequential infraction. A Green Card is also appropriate for any > infraction for which no other type of Card is appropriate. It appropriate to > issue a Green Card to a non-player person who plays the game, for the > infractions previously described. When a person is issued a Green Card, e > is ENCOURAGED to travel to the United States. > > > Create a power 2.0 rule entitled "Blue Cards", with the following text: > > A Blue Card is a type of Card that is appropriate for deliberate or negligent > infractions either where the the player responsible profited from violating > the rules or where e significantly harmed another person or the game > as a whole. The person issuing a Blue Card must, in the same message, > announce a penalty between 1 shiny and the greater of 25 shinies and the > amount the bad sport profited from the infraction, in order for the card to > be effective. E CAN additionally, in the same message, determine the > distribution of the money between Agora and the players(s) harmed, save > that e CANNOT distribute money to emself or such that it would be under > eir effective control. By default, all the money goes to Agora. > > When a Blue Card is issued, as a penalty, within the next 7 days, any player > CAN once, with 2 Support, Levy a Fine upon the bad sport. After the Fine is > Levied upon the bad sport, e SHALL endeavor in good faith to pay the fine > to Agora or the correct player(s), in accordance with the distribution laid > out by the carder. Any player CAN also act on the bad sport's behalf to do > so, > fulfilling eir obligation. > > Create a power 2.0 rule entitled "Black Cards", with the following text: > > A Black Card is a card appropriate for a person who plays the game, not > currently a player, who either broke the rules while not a player or > broke them while a player and then deregistered in bad faith. > > When a Black Card is issued, as a penalty, within the next 7 days, any player > CAN once, with Agoran Consent, Slam the Door at the bad sport. After the Door > is Slammed at a person, e CANNOT not register or take any game actions for > 30 days, rules to the contrary notwithstanding. > > --- > > -Aris
signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail
