Alex Smith wrote:
> Part of the serious problem in this case is that there isn't a whole lot
> of information around as-is; in particular, I'm not entirely sure if
> there's enough information to produce a judgement, although there may
> be. Even more interesting, the playership of a player is up for stake.
> What do we do if something important for the game is genuinely
> UNDETERMINED, and will continue generating more and more undetermined
> gamestate as time goes on?
>
> The problem on putting the onus on the CFJ caller, here, is that e may
> not be the best person to know the information. If the caller responds,
> effectively, "go on, then, continue playing with unknown gamestate", or
> worse, doesn't call the CFJ in the first place, then that puts the
> Registrar in a very difficult position; e can report Myndzi's playership
> as disputed, but continuing for ages with unknown registration statuses
> could really be damaging to Agora (c.f. Annabel, but probably not quite
> as bad unless Myndzi starts taking actions).
>
Eir playership could be ratified one way or the other; that's probably
actually the best bet.
