Zefram wrote:
Benjamin Schultz wrote:
b) comex referred to R2149 in eir arguments, and presented no other
rule in the message as provided to this CFJ. I consider this to
adequately identify the rule in question (although not as clearly as
I might prefer). PASS
Rule 1504 says that the announcement must "clearly specify" those three
items. You've shown that all three were identified in some form in the
message, but you haven't gone into whether they were clearly specified.
I think it wasn't clear. When I examined the message to process it as
a call for judgement, it appeared to me that the rule wasn't identified
at all.
The standard for clarity is not "Zefram must notice it on a first
read-through". I would look for relevant precedents, but I haven't
yet added search-by-argument-text to the CotC DB front end.
