On 18/2/16 14:02, Jiang Jiang wrote:
Hi Jonathan, I suppose not everyone have a chance to build and try this yet. By any chance you can provide a PDF test case demonstrating the feature? Then perhaps more people can comment. - Jiang
OK, I'm attaching three PDFs, all showing the same text set with the AAT font:
"Hoefler Text Italic: Smart Swashes=Word Initial Swashes,Word Final Swashes" at 18pt Here's what they show: [hoefler-italic-old-1.pdf]This is what "old" xetex (i.e. the currently-released version) does. Note that some lines -- e.g. line 5 in the first paragraph, as well as a couple of lines in the middle of the second -- look really bad, with excessively loose spacing.
[hoefler-italic-level0.pdf]This is produced with "new" (unreleased) xetex, with \XeTeXinterwordspaceshaping set to zero (disabled). Note all the word-initial and word-final swash forms. Hoefler doesn't really want to use these all over the place within the lines, but because xetex shapes each word in isolation, it doesn't know any better. This is also the effect you'd get with old xetex if the font were using OpenType or Graphite shaping features, rather than AAT: with those technologies, it never even attempts cross-space reshaping.
This serves to illustrate how the poor spacing in the "old" version arises. Note that it has the exact same line breaks; that's because old xetex is using these measurements for the words, and breaking lines on that basis. Later, it allows each line to be re-shaped as a unit (so most of the swashes disappear), but then it's too late to fix the line breaks.
[hoefler-italic-level2.pdf]Finally, here's the "good" version, with \XeTeXinterwordspaceshaping=2. Now, the final swashes appear only at line ends (as intended by the font, and as seen in the old version with the poor spacing), but now the line breaks are correct and spacing is much more consistent.
I didn't include a "level 1" PDF, as that's not really useful with a font like this.
(You'll also notice that there's letter-spacing being used to justify the text in these examples. That's a feature of the AAT font and Core Text implementation; you wouldn't see that if this were an OpenType font.)
I'll follow up with an Urdu example, too... JK
hoefler-italic-old-1.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
hoefler-italic-level0.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
hoefler-italic-level2.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
-------------------------------------------------- Subscriptions, Archive, and List information, etc.: http://tug.org/mailman/listinfo/xetex
