Wikimedia,
Hello. With respect to the Wikianswers proposal, I've been striving to find the
best level of technical detail. The current revision is available at:
https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikianswers and your feedback is welcomed.
I would like to follow up with this quick letter about some new (and hopefully
interesting) ideas pertaining to answering simple and complex natural-language
questions using multiple sources, i.e., Wikipedia ,Wikidata, and Commons. These
ideas involve processing natural-language questions to retrieve human-editable
procedural knowledge with which to answer the questions.
Artificial intelligence systems can analyze questions (and abstractions and
generalizations thereof) for cues which remind the systems of stored recipes or
procedures with which to answer the questions. Retrieved recipes or procedures
might involve structured queries (e.g., SQL or SPARQL), source code (e.g.,
Python), "wiki functions", or visualizable diagrams (i.e., human-editable
extensible workflow diagrams).
Into more technical detail, instances of questions can be categorized,
abstracted over, generalized over, into templates and data. These templates
could be used to retrieve bits of abstract procedural knowledge and these data
could be used to instantiate the bits of procedural knowledge into concrete
structured queries, algorithms, procedures, or workflows.
For clarity, here is an example:
1. Starting with a question: "What is the population of Montpelier, Vermont?"
2. Are the question, procedure, and answer cached? If so, provide the cached
answer. If not, continue on this sequence.
3. Abstract or generalize over the question instance, into a template: "What
is the population of {{X : City}}?" with data: "X = 'Montpelier, Vermont'"
* Or, perhaps, "What is the population of {{X : Q1093829}}?" with "'X =
Q26426'"
4. Using the resultant template and data, retrieve one or more abstract
structured queries, algorithms, procedures, or workflows.
5. Provide these retrieved abstract structured queries, algorithms,
procedures, or workflows with the data (X = "Montpelier, Vermont") to produce
concrete structured queries, algorithms, procedures, or workflows.
6. Execute the concrete procedures to obtain candidate answers.
7. Cache the question, procedure, and answer.
Adding human curation and wiki aspects to the architectures under discussion,
editors with adequate privileges might be able to modify or edit the stored
recipes or procedures. Editors with adequate privileges might also be able to
adjust the weights on the stored recipes or procedures for sorting them during
contextual retrieval.
In summary, these ideas intend to describe, beyond "wiki data", "wiki
procedures" with which to query multiple data sources with natural-language
questions. It may be a bit before I update the proposal with these ideas. I
wanted to share them here for discussion purposes. Thank you.
Best regards,
Adam Sobieski
_______________________________________________
Wikimedia-l mailing list -- [email protected], guidelines at:
https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Mailing_lists/Guidelines and
https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia-l
Public archives at
https://lists.wikimedia.org/hyperkitty/list/[email protected]/message/ZDNU5VY4UGT7KOPNYMCEIGNAYR6GECVI/
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
