Hello So this was broken by commit ec958a0 ( https://github.com/weewx/weewx/commit/ec958a0658612ef3bce90ab5c6e825ef0d329e8e ).
To give the history, to allow Belchertown to output / graph rxCheckPercent as discussed here https://www.mail-archive.com/weewx-user@googlegroups.com/msg21816.html, it meant we delete windDir from the Vantage archive record which means we then process the loop packets as an accumulator I'm guessing this will need the brains / knowledge of Tom to comment??? James On Wednesday, February 16, 2022 at 10:55:01 PM UTC James Taylor wrote: > Tonight's debug.... > > So I've detected that I'm not getting windDir on the archive record from > the Vantage Pro 2 on the records coming every 5 mins, compared to any > archive records received after a restart, so possibly a hardware issue. > > PRESENT - > Feb 16 21:41:02 pi weewx[5179] DEBUG weewx.drivers.vantage: Getting > archive packets since 2022-02-16 21:25:00 GMT (1645046700) > Feb 16 21:41:02 pi weewx[5179] DEBUG weewx.drivers.vantage: Gentle wake up > of console successful > Feb 16 21:41:02 pi weewx[5179] DEBUG weewx.drivers.vantage: Retrieving 1 > page(s); starting index= 0 > Feb 16 21:41:02 pi weewx[5179] DEBUG weewx.engine: REC: 2022-02-16 > 21:40:00 GMT (1645047600) 'barometer': '29.472', 'consBatteryVoltage': > 'None', 'dateTime': '1645047600', 'ET': '0.0', 'forecastRule': '192', > 'highOutTemp': '53.5', 'highRadiation': '0.0', 'highUV': '0.0', > 'inHumidity': '53.0', 'inTemp': '72.5', 'interval': '5', 'lowOutTemp': > '53.4', 'outHumidity': '86.0', 'outTemp': '53.5', 'radiation': '0.0', > 'rain': '0.0', 'rainRate': '0.0', 'rxCheckPercent': '19.645833333333332', > 'txBatteryStatus': 'None', 'usUnits': '1', 'UV': '0.0', 'wind_samples': > '23.0', 'windDir': '270.0', 'windGust': '13.0', 'windGustDir': '247.5', > 'windSpeed': '7.0' > Feb 16 21:41:02 pi weewx[5179] INFO weewx.wxxtypes: Type beaufort has been > deprecated. Use unit beaufort instead. > > MISSING - > Feb 16 22:30:15 pi weewx[5796] DEBUG weewx.engine: REC: 2022-02-16 > 22:30:00 GMT (1645050600) 'barometer': '29.511', 'consBatteryVoltage': > '4.66', 'dateTime': '1645050600', 'ET': '0.0', 'forecastRule': '122', > 'highOutTemp': '52.1', 'highRadiation': '0.0', 'highUV': '0.0', > 'inHumidity': '50.0', 'inTemp': '75.6', 'interval': '5', 'lowOutTemp': > '51.9', 'outHumidity': '78.0', 'outTemp': '51.9', 'radiation': '0.0', > 'rain': '0.0', 'rainRate': '0.0', 'rxCheckPercent': '99.9375', > 'txBatteryStatus': '0', 'usUnits': '1', 'UV': '0.0', 'wind_samples': > '117.0', 'windGust': '14.0', 'windGustDir': '247.5', 'windSpeed': '8.0' > > I've also worked out that, I appear to be getting caught up with getting a > weewx.CannotCalculate (hence a None) from calc_windDir in wxxtypes.py, > because the default calculation is software for windDir under wxservices.py > > If I set it to windDir = hardware, then it uses the loop entries and > creates the averages! > > James > On Wednesday, February 16, 2022 at 12:26:51 PM UTC James Taylor wrote: > >> Thanks Gary >> >> Yes - I forgot about the 12.5 multiples thing so yes gives me a possible >> idea on what is going to work out what has changed in behavior as the >> weewx.conf hasn't changed (apart from the version details) >> >> James >> >> On Wednesday, February 16, 2022 at 1:30:05 AM UTC gjr80 wrote: >> >>> The 4.5.1 archive record looks very much like a software generated >>> archive record, you can tell by the windDir value. The windDir value in >>> a hardware generated archive record from a VP2 appears in multiples of 12.5 >>> degrees - that is fixed and a limitation of the archive record format >>> emitted from the console/logger. In a WeeWX VP2 hardware generated archive >>> record the wind direction values will be multiples of 12.5 or None. >>> Software generated archive records contain an average of the loop packet >>> windDir values. windDir in a VP2 loop packet is in whole degrees and >>> not subject to the '12.5 degree multiple' effect. So in a software >>> generated archive record windDir will be a float, usually with a number of >>> decimal places and certainly (almost always) not a multiple of 12.5. I also >>> see THSW in the archive records, THSW is only present in the LOOP2 archive >>> packet so I am guessing you are using LOOP2 instead of the normal LOOP1 >>> packet. Should not be a problem but it's something out of the ordinary. >>> >>> Might help to see the WeeWX startup for each case and weewx.conf to >>> understand your configuration. You say record generation is set to hardware >>> in weewx.conf, that is great but not necessarily what is used by WeeWX. >>> WeeWX will try hardware and if for some reason it doesn't work/isn't >>> available WeeWX will drop back to software record generation. Always best >>> to check what is in the log. >>> >>> I would also look at the loop packets, what wind direction values do you >>> see in loop packets? What appears in the subsequent archive record? No need >>> to modify WeeWX, just run WeeWX directly >>> <http://weewx.com/docs/usersguide.htm#Running_directly> and you will >>> see loop packets and archive records direct to console. >>> >>> Gary >>> On Wednesday, 16 February 2022 at 03:02:54 UTC+10 James Taylor wrote: >>> >>>> Hello >>>> >>>> I've upgraded to weewx 4.6.2 and found out that my vantage Pro2 REC is >>>> giving a different output for windDir >>>> >>>> record_generation is set to hardware in weewx.conf >>>> >>>> I amended StdPrint to output new_archive_record to stdout and log.debug >>>> and I can see a difference >>>> >>>> 4.6.2 - >>>> Feb 15 16:30:15 pi weewx[21988] DEBUG weewx.engine: REC: 2022-02-15 >>>> 16:30:00 GMT (1644942600) 'altimeter': '29.664795850933803', 'appTemp': >>>> '44.26912313212261', 'bar_calibration': '-0.0020000000000000013', >>>> 'bar_offset': '-0.010000000000000005', 'bar_reduction': >>>> '0.0020000000000000013', 'barometer': '29.673', 'beaufort': '2', >>>> 'cloudbase': '794.2252812978254', 'consBatteryVoltage': '4.65', >>>> 'dateTime': >>>> '1644942600', 'dayET': '0.013', 'dayRain': '0.13385826690000002', >>>> 'dewpoint': '46.75340876228957', 'ET': '0.0', 'extraAlarm1': '0.0', >>>> 'extraAlarm2': '0.0', 'extraAlarm3': '0.0', 'extraAlarm4': '0.0', >>>> 'extraAlarm5': '0.0', 'extraAlarm6': '0.0', 'extraAlarm7': '0.0', >>>> 'extraAlarm8': '0.0', 'forecastIcon': '3.0', 'forecastRule': '158', >>>> 'heatindex': '47.358000000000004', 'highOutTemp': '48.5', 'highRadiation': >>>> '11.0', 'highUV': '0.0', 'hourRain': '0.0078740157', 'humidex': >>>> '49.280997613295085', 'inDewpoint': '50.40086122975667', 'inHumidity': >>>> '48.0', 'insideAlarm': '0.0', 'inTemp': '71.1', 'interval': '5', >>>> 'leafWet4': '0.0', 'lowOutTemp': '48.4', 'maxSolarRad': >>>> '46.94974186677293', 'monthET': '0.52', 'monthRain': '1.0787401509', >>>> 'outHumidity': '94.0', 'outsideAlarm1': '0.0', 'outsideAlarm2': '0.0', >>>> 'outTemp': '48.4', 'pressure': '29.21395918348061', 'pressure_raw': >>>> '29.224799999999995', 'radiation': '5.3999999999999995', 'rain': '0.0', >>>> 'rain15': '0.0', 'rain24': '0.13385826690000002', 'rainAlarm': '0.0', >>>> 'rainRate': '0.0', 'rxCheckPercent': '97.375', 'soilLeafAlarm1': '0.0', >>>> 'soilLeafAlarm2': '0.0', 'soilLeafAlarm3': '0.0', 'soilLeafAlarm4': '0.0', >>>> 'stormRain': '0.13385826690000002', 'stormStart': '1644883200.0', >>>> 'sunrise': '1644912960.0', 'sunset': '1644949080.0', 'sunshineDuration': >>>> '0.0', 'THSW': '45.0', 'trendIcon': '-20.0', 'txBatteryStatus': '0', >>>> 'usUnits': '1', 'UV': '0.0', 'wind_samples': '114.0', 'windchill': >>>> '45.762013144176095', 'windDir': 'None', 'windGust': '10.0', 'windGust10': >>>> '10.0', 'windGustDir': '247.5', 'windGustDir10': '247.0', 'windrun': >>>> '0.5', >>>> 'windSpeed': '6.0', 'windSpeed2': '5.7', 'windSpeed10': '5.0', 'yearET': >>>> '1.13', 'yearRain': '1.5275590458000001' >>>> >>>> Back to 4.5.1 and everything is good ( windDir: 237.52965750482582). >>>> >>>> Feb 15 16:50:15 pi weewx[22480] DEBUG weewx.engine: REC: 2022-02-15 >>>> 16:50:00 GMT (1644943800) altimeter: 29.656827096532094, appTemp: >>>> 45.77889412649187, bar_calibration: -0.0020000000000000013, bar_offset: >>>> -0.010000000000000005, barometer: 29.665, bar_reduction: >>>> 0.0020000000000000013, beaufort: 1, cloudbase: 730.1419634508915, >>>> consBatteryVoltage: 4.65, dateTime: 1644943800, dayET: 0.013, dayRain: >>>> 0.13385826690000002, dewpoint: 46.83537536081608, ET: 0.0, extraAlarm1: >>>> 0.0, extraAlarm2: 0.0, extraAlarm3: 0.0, extraAlarm4: 0.0, extraAlarm5: >>>> 0.0, extraAlarm6: 0.0, extraAlarm7: 0.0, extraAlarm8: 0.0, forecastIcon: >>>> 3.0, forecastRule: 158, heatindex: 47.185, highOutTemp: 48.2, >>>> highRadiation: 7.0, highUV: 0.0, hourRain: 0.0, humidex: >>>> 49.11495517097403, >>>> inDewpoint: 50.309529357501425, inHumidity: 48.0, insideAlarm: 0.0, >>>> inTemp: >>>> 71.0, interval: 5, leafWet4: 0.0, lowOutTemp: 48.1, maxSolarRad: 0.0, >>>> monthET: 0.52, monthRain: 1.0787401509, outHumidity: 95.0, outsideAlarm1: >>>> 0.0, outsideAlarm2: 0.0, outTemp: 48.2, pressure: 29.206088977429996, >>>> pressure_raw: 29.21954545454549, radiation: 4.2, rain: 0.0, rain15: 0.0, >>>> rain24: 0.13385826690000002, rainAlarm: 0.0, rainRate: 0.0, >>>> rxCheckPercent: >>>> 98.22916666666666, soilLeafAlarm1: 0.0, soilLeafAlarm2: 0.0, >>>> soilLeafAlarm3: 0.0, soilLeafAlarm4: 0.0, stormRain: 0.13385826690000002, >>>> stormStart: 1644883200.0, sunrise: 1644912960.0, sunset: 1644949080.0, >>>> sunshineDuration: 0.0, THSW: 45.666666666666664, trendIcon: -20.0, >>>> txBatteryStatus: 0, usUnits: 1, UV: 0.0, windchill: 48.2, windDir: >>>> 237.52965750482582, windGust: 6.0, windGust10: 0.7, windGustDir: 225.0, >>>> windGustDir10: 225.0, windrun: 0.25, wind_samples: 115.0, windSpeed: 3.0, >>>> windSpeed10: 3.0, windSpeed2: 3.2, yearET: 1.13, yearRain: 1.52755904580000 >>>> >>>> I've issued a clear-memory just in case it was corrupted, but I'm now >>>> thinking something else is going on. The Loop data is fine and mqtt is >>>> working as expected. >>>> >>>> Any idea on how to debug this some more? >>>> >>>> Thanks >>>> >>>> James >>>> >>> -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "weewx-user" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to weewx-user+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/weewx-user/4a42acbd-8470-42a4-9a37-77bda416cfd0n%40googlegroups.com.
