I didn't test federation, but otherwise the RC looks good - off course we still need to address the open issues in the Jira.
On Fri, Sep 13, 2013 at 3:35 AM, Joseph Gentle <jose...@gmail.com> wrote: > On Thu, Sep 12, 2013 at 12:36 PM, Christian Grobmeier > <grobme...@gmail.com> wrote: > > Am 12.09.13 20:35, schrieb Ali Lown: > >> It seems nobody else is able to give feedback at this point. > >> Christian raised some things that are worth doing, so I may as well > >> start again with RC5, which I will push up in a few weeks time. [It is > >> a bit too busy for me ATM.] > >> > >> Hopefully, by being a bit later, people won't be on holiday, so will > >> be able to review it. :P > > I would say save the time for now. > > > > It has been 2 weeks time for voting. This project has seen messages. > > It's september, not mid of august. > > We got 1 (!) community vote. Vincente mentioned he is away (thats fine) > > and John is not so much into gory technical details (accepted so far). > > > > But where were the others? Is it really holidays which prevents the > > vote? Do we ALL have holidays at the same time? > > > > Before we move on with a new RC, i would like to know from the people > > listed here: > > http://people.apache.org/committers-by-project.html#wave > > why they didn't vote.** > > > > Was it really holidays? No interest? No time? > > > > It has been *a lot* of work for Ali to deal with the ASF release > > procedures and kick out multiple RCs. It would be worth to know if he > > should continue and if there will be any voters in the future. If there > > is nobody who is willing to open a zip file, look into it and send out a > > +1, then its really alarming. It took me 30 minutes or so to check the > > release. This is not so much. > > > > I have hoped the excitement in the project after John and a few others > > appeared was so big that we would have managed to get a new release out > > for review. If others, maybe Incubator Shepherds* look at this project > > now, they would think: no community. > > > > Please let me - us - know what you who are on the list above prevented > > to vote**. > > > > Cheers*** > > Christian > > > > * Incubator Shepherds are Incubator PMC people, who look independently > > from the mentor on the activity of the project and provide a second > > insight for the report > > ** Of course I don't want you to speak out anything which should be kept > > private - remember this is a public list. I just want to know: is there > > a realistic chance that we ever get more than 3 votes? 3 are required to > > get it out, but given the huge list of committers we should get more > votes. > > *** I am not a native speaker - and I hope my email doesn't sound to > > angry. I am not. I would be dissappointed if it finally turns out that > > we have lost the energy and steam of the past days > > I was happy a few RCs ago, and I mailed to say so. If most of the > changes are in licensing files, well, whatever. > > I haven't tried to install the current RC. The thing I'd want to check > is federation, but unless anything has changed in the last couple > years, I expect it to be a nightmare to set up. And without manually > trying that out, I don't have any more comments to add. > > Thats my thoughts, since you asked for them. > > J > > > > > > > > >> > >> Ali > > > > >
