On Sun, Nov 20, 2011 at 10:46 AM, David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:

>
> I want to make one observation for you and others to consider.  If the
> output power delivered during the  test were in the range of 500 kW, then
> all of the vapor exiting toward
> the heat exchanger would be high quality.
>

Agreed.


> There would be little water collected within the trap set by the HVAC
> engineer and every measurement obtained during the
> October 28 test would fall into place.
>

The simple temperature measurement is consistent with high quality steam,
and the little water collected is consistent with high quality steam.

But the temperature as a function of time is *not* consistent with high
quality steam produced as soon as boiling begins because that requires an
implausible increase in power transfer (and corresponding discontinuous
increase in temperature of a large thermal mass), and simultaneous turn-on
of 107 ecats, exactly at the onset of boiling. That is not believable, and
since the temperature measurement is also consistent with a scenario in
which neither of those are necessary, that scenario is more likely.

This match between theory and measured fact is not a coincidence and should
> stand under any honest scrutiny.
>

It does not bear up under the scrutiny of the need for an 8-fold increase
in power transfer, and simultaneous turn-on of 107 ecats.



> The skeptic position
> is that very little if any of the water was vaporized.  This is total non
> sense and will be easily dismissed when facing the real world conditions.
>

You have said this many times, but you have so far not supported it. The
only argument against low vaporization is the absence of water collected in
the trap, but that is not convincing because:

(1) the valve to the trap appears to have been closed at 3:00, even though
Rossi said it was open throughout. So that means we don't have any reason
to believe it was open at all.

(2) the trap is not placed at a low point (bottom of a U), so that it would
not likely collect much separated fluid, even in annular flow.

(3) a trap would be useless to collect liquid from a fast moving mist, and
it is quite easy to generate a mist, even from low quality steam. Rossi
could be using a nozzle of some sort at the output to each ecat, or a coil
of narrow conduit would do it, or even an ultrasonic nebulizer. The point
is, we don't know, and nothing was measured to verify that that trap would
collect the liquid from low quality steam formed from the ecats.


I prefer to start with the most basic assumptions and then build upon them
> as we prove whether or not Rossi has a true system.  Each proven point will
> lead to further
> proofs as the model advances.
>

We have very few actual measurements, and the ones we have are only
according to Rossi and his engineer. For the calculation of output power,
we have only input flow rate, temperature, and volume of liquid collected
from what appears to be nothing more than a tee in the conduit.

We will not have the luxury of generating proofs of anything based on that.
To me, it's pretty simple. The measurements are strictly consistent with
power output anywhere from 70 kW to 470 kW.

The time dependence of the temperature during warm-up and boiling suggest
strongly that the power was much closer to 70 kW for a considerable time
after the onset of boiling. Since no further information is available after
that, it is *possible* that the power was 70 kW throughout. It's also
possible it increased gradually throughout the boiling period, but if
you're looking for proof that it did, there is none.

If we are to proceed, I suggest that a good starting point is to estimate
> the pressure within the steam output pipes.  My first guess would be ~5
> psi, but I am confident that
> we have some members of vortex who can obtain a more accurate calculation
> so I yield the floor to them.
>
>
I don't see the point of this. If we agree that the output is at the
boiling point of water, which seems reasonable given its stability, then
the pressure can be looked up, and for a bp of 105C, that's about 1.2 bar
or 17.5 psi (3 psi gauge). But the main thing is that if the temperature is
at the boiling point, we have no independent measure of the degree of
vaporization. It's the same temperature for 1% and for 99%.

Reply via email to