Rossi said:

The volume free for the water is about 30 liters, so that to fill up it are
> necessary about 2 hours ( the pump of the primary circuit pumps about 15
> liters per hour) . . .
>

This is confusing yet strangely helpful.

Didn't he say there are four cells in each reactor box? There are 4 pumps on
the table there. It is multiplexed. (Why not just make 4 boxes?)

Anyway, there are multiple cells and only one cell was in use during this
test.

I assume each of the 4 cells has its own reservoir, so 30 L / 4 = 7.4 L.

Let us assume the primary loop flow rate was 0.9 mL/s, and it took about 2
hours to fill up the reservoir. The graph shows no water or steam going into
the heat exchanger for 2 hours, and Rossi said 2 hours above. 2 hours * 0.9
mL/s = ~6.5 L. Close enough!

The temperature of the water is around 120°C, evidently under some pressure.
Ambient is around 20°C so . . .  120°C - 20°C * 6500 g = 650,000 calories =
2.7 MJ stored heat in the water.

Lewan's minimum estimate is 2 kW. 2.7 MJ / 2,000 J/s means all of the stored
heat in the water must be extracted by the cooling water flow in 23 minutes,
less time than it takes to replace all the water. It would have to magically
surrender all 2.7 MJ and be room temperature 23 minutes after the power goes
off. Yet 4 hours after it went off, the water was still boiling, the reactor
surface was still hot, and the hose was still hot enough to burn someone.

Krivit thinks the water "stored" 33 MJ, which magically came out twice as
shown by the calorimetry: once before heat after death, and again during
it. I guess Maxwell's Demon turns those megajoules around and pushes them
right back in to the water. Anyway, assuming I am correct about the volume
of the reservoir the temperature of that water would be 1230°C.

- Jed

Reply via email to