Alan Munday wrote:
By default, there is no duplication. sa-update will update only the stock rules. However, there have been additional channels created for sa-update
to allow it to update the SARE rules as well.  You just add the ones you
want to your sa-update channels file.

One advantage RDJ seems to have is that it won't leave you in the situation of a non functional SA because your updated rules don't lint.

Advantage over sa-update? Other than the issue with 3.1.6 (only), there shouldn't be any issues with how sa-update lints rules. I think the only way you'll end up without a working ruleset is if problems with the file system containing your local state directory start occurring half way through the update process. At that point, a working SA ruleset probably won't be your main concern.


If using sa-update for SARE rules, are these stored in the same location as the originals or are they downloaded to the /var/lib/spamassassin tree?

What originals? SARE rules you saved somewhere (probably /etc/mail/spamassassin)? If yes, you'll want to remove those before switching to getting SARE rules via sa-update.

All rules obtained via sa-update will be stored under your local state directory which is often /var/lib/spamassassin.


If so is there a migration guide somewhere on moving from RDJ to sa-update?

- remove existing SARE rules from wherever you've got them
- decide on which provider of the SARE channel(s) you're going to use
- follow that providers directions

See this wiki page for about the same info:
http://wiki.apache.org/spamassassin/SareChannels

Here's my how to on it:
http://daryl.dostech.ca/sa-update/sare/sare-sa-update-howto.txt


Daryl

Reply via email to