I'm still catching up on this thread, but I have some points:
1) Matt's taking a beating, and he shouldn't be. I see his concerns. I might not agree, but he has legitimate reasons for bringing it up, and only serves to help all of us.
2) Perhaps an FP that turns up on mutliple lists, should really, REALLY send up a red flag on this domain. If 2+ URIBL lists with seperate resources find this domain to be spam, then something MUST be up! For even if they are submitted manually to both lists, they are looked at by humans. Who usually do more then 2 seconds of reading!
The real point is, WHY was an FP on 2 different lists?
3) Companies that find themselves on these lists, should stand up and say "WTF?" and find out why!
4) I still love Matt. And not in that Brokeback kind of way. Well....maybe..... I wish I could quit him!
--Chris
