Le 30.03.23 à 12:43, Lionel Giard a écrit :
we use the same idea for amenity=fuel where it just shows
the place where there is one or more fuel pump.
in no case did amentiy=fuel designate a pump and then be changed
to designate all the pumps in the same location.
it you really want to have an amenity to keep
the same idea as for fossil amenity,
why not amenity=charing_place
but keep the current in-use meaning amenity=charging_station inchanged
And it also seems logical to use "man_made" category to tag
the individual charge points as we do for fuel pumps.
that doesn't answer my objection: don't change the meaning
of an existing tag :
For years we will end up with a tag with two meanings: the old and
the new and it will be impossible to review the old tag since part
of the new meaning (amenity=charging_station = a site of
man_made=charging_station) uses the same tag as the current meaning
(amenity=charging_station = a charging station, that may be part of
a bigger site)
not being able to migrate from the old to the new schema is the worst
thing you can do to destroy data quality
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
