Dear all,
Hungerburg wrote Mon Sep 26 2022 22:19:03 GMT+0200
Nearly two weeks passed since the RfC started. Quite some changes have happened. I’d like to invite a second reading, to help weed out remaining problems. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/highway=scramble
"use of hands is required" is not defined at all, thus stays fully subjective: My sister needs hands where I do not even start to think about using hands, most people living in German cities will use hands where people from rural areas of Peru's Andes won't because their daily routine ways differ so much. → This massively reduces the added value of highway=scramble and invites for edit wars. I posted some definition possibilities in my mail of 2022-09-20, 17:00 scramble=grade* is mentioned in the current proposal. The grades definition posted earlier in this thread tells
On grade 2 and 3 scrambles it’s worthwhile taking a rope at least 30m long, some eight-foot slings, HMS karabiners and maybe a very small rack, half a dozen large nuts and hexes at most.
The proposal excludes any scrambles using equipment, so forbids all scrambles of grades 2+3 to be tagged as highway=scramble. Thus, only scramble=grade1 remains by definition, so it cannot add any information and shall be removed from the proposal. Regards, Georg _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
