Le 26.08.19 à 00:18, Joseph Eisenberg a écrit : > What should we do with a page like Tag:landcover=dunes? I already > tried adding a mention that natural=dune was more common and mentioned > on the Talk page that "dune" is a landform, not a landcover
the first sentence on the wiki is enought to fully describe the mess in your argument. "the dune landform (natural=dune) and for areas of sand (natural=sand)" so a landform and a landcover in the same key. exactly the same problem you're criticizing. so no, landcover is probably no worse than landuse. natural=* description try to explain that the common "meaning" for is value is "natural physical land features, including ones that have been modified by humans" but that also "need" to be used to "full artificial" (ex a full artificial water pond). don't be surprised that some people are not satisfied with this kind of key whose category changes according to the value. _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
