On 07/12/18 06:49, Mark Wagner wrote:
On Thu, 6 Dec 2018 17:54:44 +0100
Rory McCann <r...@technomancy.org> wrote:
On 06/12/2018 08:38, Mark Wagner wrote:
Yellowstone National Park has attracted a fair few bare
"tourism=attraction" objects. How would you tag the following:
* Boiling River and Firehole Swimming Area, naturally-heated
stretches of river that are popular for swimming.
natural=water + leisure=swimming_area ? natural=water +
sport=swimming ?
Seems reasonable.
Except for sport. Sport implies competition, are there marked lanes for this
competition? I'd think not. So I would leave sport out of it.
* Petrified Tree, a large, petrified section of tree trunk.
natural=tree? natural=petrified_tree ?
"Tree" is misleading. "natural=petrified_tree" would be good, except
it gets zero hits in TagInfo.
petrified gets a hits in taginfo... natural=petrified_forest
Possibly tag as
natural=tree, tree=petrified
or
natural=tree, petrified=yes
There are a few names with petrified in them.
* Soda Butte, the rock formation left behind by a long-extinct
geyser.
natural=rock ? natural=rock_formation ?
"natural=rock" looks good.
* Norris Geyser Basin, Upper Geyser Basin, Artist Paint Pots,
Fountain Paint Pots, and other named groups of thermal features.
natural=geyser ?
"natural=geyser" is already in use for geysers. Applying it to entire
geyser basins would be like using the same tag for both single trees
and forests. (It would also be inaccurate, since these basins usually
contain a mix of geysers, fumaroles, hot springs, and occasionally mud
pots.)
* Roaring Mountain, a hillside that contains a large number of steam
vents.
place=locality ? natural=peak ? natural=hill ?
"locality" might work, but it's even more generic than "tourist
attraction". "Peak" or "hill" don't work -- the summit is almost a mile
to the southwest of the actual point of interest.
I'd add description=hill side
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
