On 20/06/18 03:10, Christoph Hormann wrote:
On Tuesday 19 June 2018, Frederik Ramm wrote:
Perhaps it would make sense to treat the iD editor and the tagging
presets it uses as two different projects that are conceptually
separate enough so that the tagging presets as rolled out on osm.org
can be curated by a group that is separate from the editor writers?
The question in that case would of course be how the group of people
supervising this list is selected and what the guiding principles of
this project are.
But the general direction of your idea seems right - breaking up the
direct connection between editors and presets, maintaining presets in a
form that is interoperable between editors and offering a choice which
presets to use to editor users and - in case of iD - editor
deployments. In such a situation you would not need to worry about who
controls an individual collection of tagging presets any more since
there would probably be sufficient diversity for this to be self
regulating.
Perhaps there needs to be options of which preset collection you want.
You could prefer the presets made by group 1 .. or group 6.
Each preset group can be made by separate people or collections of people.
You might even be able to select the present group on the fly.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
