On Tuesday 02 May 2017 11:25:10 Tobias Wrede wrote: > I would understand it the same way. To be a little bit more concrete: If > you come from the northbound Gloucester Rd via the nothern loop (way > 46615969) onto Victoria Park Rd (way 46615970 and onward) you must > continue on the northern bit of westbound Gloucester Rd (way 244383612) > and you are not allowed to take the middle or southern Gloucester Rd > (244383597 and 486608995). If you come from the secondary Gloucester Rd > (way 486608999), the other bit of Victoria Park Rd (way 87081210), > Cannon St or Percival St, though, you may continue on either the > northern, middle or southern part of Gloucester Rd. > > This arrangement looks a bit strange to me. Is this what you intended to > tag?
Yes, exactly. > If there is such rule set in place on is there not any physical > barrier on the road preventing the lane changes? The rule is on but there are only solid lines and police cars nearby without any physical barrier. > That case might warrant > splitting the raod into two parallel segments. It was originally tagged so, but according to the discussions earlier titled "Tagging 'advance' turn restrictions", On Thursday 06 April 2017 00:29:49 Tom Pfeifer wrote: > On 05.04.2017 23:19, Warin wrote: > > Where the solid lines start have a separate way for each lane > > Do _not_. Separate ways are used when the roads are physically separated, > not when a white line is painted. Lane mapping would get you reverted. > > > this way routing engines will regard them as separate roads and stop > > trying to get you from one lane to another. > > OSM is not only for car routing. Imagine a chicken wants to cross the road, > and stumbles over all those separate ways just representing lanes. > > > Then do your turn restrictions. > > Turn restrictions are not used for restricting the change of lanes. > > > On 06-Apr-17 04:09 AM, Kevin Kenny wrote: > >> Do we have a scheme for tagging such a beast? > > You can combine turn:lanes [1] with change:lanes [2], the first describe > which lane you have to use for which turn, the second where you can change > lanes and where not. > > [1] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:turn > [2] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:change > > If you want to show us the current situation, you can drive along with the > mapillary app and upload, so you don't need to show outdated G***** > pictures ;-) I remapped those parts, but in order to prevent routing engines from turning illegally, I had to add a lot of restrictions onto the road, including the use of multi via-way where basically no currently available routing engines support. > > > Thank god I never had to drive own-handed in HK. :-) Even commercial systems like Google Maps can't be trusted here because it cannot handle this situation. Michael -- Sent from KMail _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
