On 18/04/2016 9:33 PM, Mikael Nordfeldth wrote:
Warin 61sundowner at gmail.com wrote:
That has "Shot-put" ... note the dash, not an uderscore. So I am back
to thinking about it.
Hi again! As I commented on the wiki talk page for "sport=shot-put"[1] I
believe the value should be normalised to "shot_put" regardless if it's
the English "shot-put" or American "shot put".
This replacement, "-" to "_", is a typical behaviour in programming (and
as the key=value setup isn't for humans anyway,
Err key=values is very much for humans!
If it were not then the key 'sport could become 'Sp' as there would be no need
for more than 2704 keys .. similarly for values.
I think it's logical and
appropriate to use programming practices).
In general it is good to avoid the "-" character in single words/phrases
to avoid cumbersome regular expressions (where - has to be escaped) etc.
As the program would be looking for matching values (For x = 1 to y;If A(x)=B?
then use symbol for soccer, exit for;next x) there is no need for an 'escape'
for the - ... only a need to separate up the string by the ';' character in
sport values.
as well as special meanings ("start-finish" enumerations for example).
Also all the tags out there, except recently changed by you,
5 off have been changed as a check
are labeled
"shot_put".
I have added a few more new ones
I guess "shotput" could probably also work, but given the
prevalence of "shot_put" I think that choice is the path of least mistyping.
[1] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Tag:sport%3Dshot-put
I have placed what I think are the desired outcomes for this short on the above
wiki page. I have not linked it to other pages so it is not well advertised.
I would like other people to comment on how they see this.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
