I agree with Martin. We need to distinguish between the building=kiosk that is a one room solitary building, from the shop=kiosk activity because somewhere the kiosk moved from the solitary building to some windows in a bigger building.
Gianfra > Date: Mon, 18 Oct 2010 09:16:19 +0200 > From: dieterdre...@gmail.com > To: tagging@openstreetmap.org > Subject: Re: [Tagging] shop=kiosk > > 2010/10/18 Noel David Torres Taño <env...@rolamasao.org>: > > On Lunes 18 Octubre 2010 04:08:13 Richard Welty escribió: > >> On 10/17/10 11:00 PM, j...@jfeldredge.com wrote: > >> > So, are you saying that a shop that was located in a kiosk building, but > >> > sold merchandise other than "cigarettes, newspapers, sweets, snacks and > >> > beverages" would have a tag building=kiosk, but would not have the tag > >> > shop=kiosk? > >> > >> what of "kiosks" in malls selling cheap jewelry, watches, cell phones, > >> etc.? do they not count? > > If they do not sell "cigarettes, newspapers, sweets, snacks and beverages" > > they are not shop=kiosk. They are shop=jewelry or shop=boutique or > > shop=mobile_phone. > > > which part of "cigarettes, newspapers, sweets, snacks and beverages" > is obligatory, which isn't? What if they sell only newspapers and > tickets for the public transport? I guess it's a newsagent then? What > do they have to add to their offer in order to become an OSM kiosk? > > Around here there are lots of kiosks (the building type) that only > sell flowers, or books, or newspapers, or food. These are all _OR_s. > They do IMHO qualify to be called kiosk in natural language. There is > almost none of them that sells cigarettes though (local cultural > habits). > > To the typology: kiosks are traditionally freestanding small > solitaires, but in some regions the meaning of kiosk evolved and now > is applicable also to shops selling through a hole in the wall (the > examples given above by Peter). Still this doesn't mean that any shop > selling cigarettes and newspapers will qualify for kiosk: this is > still about typology (and in this I disagree with Ulf's definition > that kiosk has nothing to do with typology: it is a word for 2 similar > kinds of typology (or better one which is selling through a window > which is common to both subtypes). > > cheers, > Martin > > _______________________________________________ > Tagging mailing list > Tagging@openstreetmap.org > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
