We definitely need an "average speed" tag, to improve routing.

In my area the road speeds vary a lot depending on the amount of traffic, which means that the "fastest" routes selected by routing algorithms are often not good because the journey goes along roads where the traffic is nearly stationary, whereas slightly different routes would be along 'empty' roads! The tagged or implicit 'max_speed' is useless as a routing speed for most of the day on these roads.

We would need to:
1) Tag the 'average' or 'typical speed'
2) Associate those speeds with time of the day/week.
3) Allow specification of different speeds/time for both directions of a way (rush hour traffic is often only in one direction). 4) Allow the mode of transport to be specified (e.g if there are bus lanes, then buses would have a different speed to car stuck in rush hour traffic).

I've done some very cursory searching on the wiki, but not found any suggestions/proposals for this yet.

"rush hour" traffic speeds are much more regular and consistent than "the fastest speed you can drive down this curving country road", so maybe the latter is a separate tag/discussion.


_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Reply via email to