I saw in the Lockergnome newsletter I received today, Spamassassin was 
slammed big time.  I do see his point though.  Does SA really do that 
great of a job with newsletters and journals?

Just as an exercise, I ran though my journals folder though SA and it 
wasn't pretty.  These are all mailing lists that I subscribe to in this 
folder.  There were about 2000 emails covering about two years, about 
100 recent ones from the last month or so and the rest were things that 
I haven't gotten around to deleting yet.

Out of those, 213 hit over 5 and a lot of them scored in double digits. 
  Pretty much every one of the Lockergnome journals scored about 15.  I 
never see this since as a matter of habit procmail filters all my 
mailing lists to another folder before SA sees any of them.

Is this just the journals I read or does this seem like a really big 
problem to others?  I know these can be whitelisted (and in my case, 
procmail takes care of them), but if an ISP, for example, is going to 
use SA, lots of people are going to get legitmate mail filtered and will 
have to go hunting for it in their caught mail folder.

I think it does a great job with personal emails, you know, letters to 
mom and friends, but mailing lists seem to contain so many of the spammy 
sorts of things, they really don't score well.

If anybody wants to look at the emails, let me know and I'll send the 
file of emails that failed the test along.

Kerry.


_______________________________________________
Spamassassin-talk mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/spamassassin-talk

Reply via email to