Re: [VOTE RESULT] (was: [VOTE] Release Wave 0.4 based on RC3)

2013-06-16 Thread Christian Grobmeier
Hi Ali, its ok if you just pass on the link to the vote result. No need to search for the individual results, its really too much work. though I appreciate your precision, if you like it like that it's OK. It just want to save some time :-) I believe ML update all couple of hours, but I seriously

Re: A Call To Developers

2013-06-16 Thread Christian Grobmeier
Ross Gardler was last year on the ASF board and is a well-respected community member. He knows a lot about driving open source projects, because knowing that is also his day job. On Apache Con EU he held a great presentation on open source risks: http://de.slideshare.net/rgardler/managing-project-

Life at the incubator

2013-06-16 Thread Christian Grobmeier
hello folks, since there are a lot of new people around here, I thought I would share this: "Life In The Apache Incubator by Jukka Zitting at ApacheCon EU…" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KopPbWS87fw Its a presentation by Jukka on the Incubator from last year. If you prefer video, instead of rea

Re: Wave and OpenOffice

2013-06-16 Thread Michael MacFadden
All, What we would need to do to support integration with Open Office, or any other app, is abstract our OT Core Engine in two ways. First it would need to become a stand alone service that other apps could hook in to. Second we would need to change the operations to be more generic than the curr

Re: [VOTE RESULT] (was: [VOTE] Release Wave 0.4 based on RC3)

2013-06-16 Thread Michael MacFadden
I know I asked this before, but when we are ready, just let me know I would be happy to post the artifact somewhere typical and update the web site. I'll also submit some news items to various web sites. ~Michael On 6/16/13 8:22 AM, "Christian Grobmeier" wrote: >Hi Ali, > >its ok if you just p

Re: Wave and OpenOffice

2013-06-16 Thread Dave
On 16/06/13 09:29, Michael MacFadden wrote: All, What we would need to do to support integration with Open Office, or any other app, is abstract our OT Core Engine in two ways. First it would need to become a stand alone service that other apps could hook in to. Second we would need to change t

Re: Wave and OpenOffice

2013-06-16 Thread Michael MacFadden
I took a look at walk around when it was first announced. Admittedly, I would need to go back and take a look at it again. I do remember it being more decoupled than was was in WiaB. I don't remember if it was (in my opinion) sufficiently abstract. I seem to remember there were still things lik

Re: Wave and OpenOffice

2013-06-16 Thread John Blossom
Michael, Thank you very much for engaging this topic. Your observations highlighted some of the key challenges and concerns that I have factored into the presentation deck that I shared earlier: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1pNsrX26947QH89Ot3k62nlKKSRFLmVgBWxcIEne8VYI/edit?usp=sharing

OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Rob Weir
I'm not subscribed to this list, but Christian Grobmeier pointed me to John's post about how OT and Wave could be relevant to OpenOffice. I wanted to mention that the idea is being discussed, but at the standards level. The default document format for OpenOffice is Open Document Format (ODF), whi

Re: Wave and OpenOffice

2013-06-16 Thread Joseph Gentle
On Sun, Jun 16, 2013 at 2:25 AM, Dave wrote: > On 16/06/13 09:29, Michael MacFadden wrote: >> >> All, >> >> What we would need to do to support integration with Open Office, or any >> other app, is abstract our OT Core Engine in two ways. First it would >> need to become a stand alone service tha

wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Dave
I couldn't find an overview of the various bits of the wiab server, and how they plumb together. So from a couple of hours digging into the codebase, I knocked up the attached diagram. I didn't include the Concurrency and Document/Conversation structure, as I suspect these are better visualise

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Dave
and now as a link, rather than attachment: http://i.imgur.com/gv4qMJY.png On 16/06/13 17:11, Dave wrote: I couldn't find an overview of the various bits of the wiab server, and how they plumb together. So from a couple of hours digging into the codebase, I knocked up the attached diagram. I

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Christian Grobmeier
Please note, Rob is PMC member of the Apache OpenOffice project and knows a lot on the project and how it operates. On Sun, Jun 16, 2013 at 5:00 PM, Rob Weir wrote: > I'm not subscribed to this list, but Christian Grobmeier pointed me to > John's post about how OT and Wave could be relevant to O

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Michael MacFadden
Rob, I would be interested in continuing this conversation. I have been working with the top minds in OT for the past few years. I am excited to hear the OO is interested in an OT supported mechanism. How far along are you in the process? ~Michael On Jun 16, 2013, at 11:00 AM, Rob Weir wrote:

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Upayavira
Note he's not subscribed - you'll need to cc. Upayavira On Sun, Jun 16, 2013, at 07:51 PM, Michael MacFadden wrote: > Rob, > > I would be interested in continuing this conversation. I have been > working with the top minds in OT for the past few years. I am excited to > hear the OO is interested

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread John Blossom
Thanks, Rob, it seems that this opens up interesting doors for down-the-road variants of OpenOffice based on Wave editing models and data models. The challenge and the opportunity is that Wave's OT model acts on the body of a document, so conversations and collaborations can become the body of a mo

Re: A Call To Developers

2013-06-16 Thread John Blossom
Thanks for Ross' slides, I look forward to reviewing them. J On Jun 16, 2013 3:30 AM, "Christian Grobmeier" wrote: > Ross Gardler was last year on the ASF board and is a well-respected > community member. He knows a lot about driving open source projects, > because knowing that is also his day jo

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Bruno Gonzalez (aka stenyak)
I don't know the accuracy of the image, but I vote for its inclusion in the wiki. On Sun, Jun 16, 2013 at 6:20 PM, Dave wrote: > and now as a link, rather than attachment: > > http://i.imgur.com/gv4qMJY.png > > > > On 16/06/13 17:11, Dave wrote: > >> I couldn't find an overview of the various b

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Ali Lown
+1 to putting on the wiki. On 16 June 2013 21:07, Bruno Gonzalez (aka stenyak) wrote: > I don't know the accuracy of the image, but I vote for its inclusion in the > wiki. > > > On Sun, Jun 16, 2013 at 6:20 PM, Dave wrote: > >> and now as a link, rather than attachment: >> >> http://i.imgur.com/

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Yuri Z
It's not totally accurate IMHO. I would prefer some kind of mind map that can be edited and improved over time. On Mon, Jun 17, 2013 at 12:54 AM, Ali Lown wrote: > +1 to putting on the wiki. > > On 16 June 2013 21:07, Bruno Gonzalez (aka stenyak) > wrote: > > I don't know the accuracy of the i

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Sam Nelson
Although I haven't tested it myself, there is a mindmap gadget in Rizzoma (separate from the mindmap view). If that could be used to build this diagram then Rizzoma already supports anonymous access of public topics, and can be embedded in an octane, perhaps in the wiki? Yuri Z wrote: >It's n

Re: FW: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Rob Weir
Adding Svante Schubert to the thread, from the ODF Toolkit project. He also chairs the subcommittee at OASIS that has been looking at OT for change tracking in ODF. On Sun, Jun 16, 2013 at 6:15 PM, Michael MacFadden wrote: > > > On 6/16/13 2:51 PM, "Michael MacFadden" > wrote: > >>Rob, >> >>I w

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Dave
Sure - What tool would you suggest Yuri? I just used what was to hand - OO Draw - but can upload the source somewhere? For my education, what are the inaccuracies? Dave On 16/06/13 22:58, Yuri Z wrote: It's not totally accurate IMHO. I would prefer some kind of mind map that can be edited an

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Michael MacFadden
After hooking up with Google for wave. I have been the lead architect for an OT framework much like the real time drive API being built at my company. I am encouraging my developers to reengage the apache community so we can actively contribute back. We have also done a in depth literature revie

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Sam Nelson
An example of what I was talking about before: https://rizzoma.com/topic/4f4d5d1aeb337f9307458e1ec8919881/ This can be embedded using: https://rizzoma.com/embedded/4f4d5d1aeb337f9307458e1ec8919881/"; frameborder="0" allowfullscreen> Although the tool is not very advanced, it does allow for easy c

Re: FW: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread John Blossom
Thanks for joining the conversation, Rob. I think that one key difference in Wave - both as it is and as it could be - is that the data model is based on how ideas and conversations form, not necessarily a final artifact. It feasible, for example for Wave data structures to encapsulate chat/convers

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Zachary “Gamer_Z . ” Yaro
As an alternative, do Google Drawings support embedding? —Zachary “Gamer_Z.” Yaro On Jun 16, 2013 7:21 PM, "Sam Nelson" wrote: > An example of what I was talking about before: > https://rizzoma.com/topic/4f4d5d1aeb337f9307458e1ec8919881/ > > This can be embedded using: > src="https://rizzoma.co

Re: wiab server overview diagram

2013-06-16 Thread Dave
Apparently yes: http://webapps.stackexchange.com/questions/14710/is-there-a-way-to-get-an-embed-link-for-a-google-drawing Rather than hosted externally, I wonder if the source for such documentation would be better hosted (and owned) by the Apache project though - maybe alongside the other docs

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Joseph Gentle
Sounds interesting. Where is this going to be held? It might be interesting for a few people on this list, too. -J On Sun, Jun 16, 2013 at 4:08 PM, Michael MacFadden wrote: > After hooking up with Google for wave. I have been the lead architect for an > OT framework much like the real time driv

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread John Blossom
Joseph, my thought is that we can have a Google+ Hangout and invite everyone in the Wave community and beyond interested in OT and related issues. Doesn't have to be perfect, we just need to get the dialogue.rolling, it seems. We can always have more. Say Weds or Thursday around 1700 UT+1? Pick a

Re: OpenOffice and Wave

2013-06-16 Thread Michael MacFadden
A google hang out amongst wave developers is a great idea. However this is not a substitute for presenting and discussing the future of OT with the active research community. ~Michael On Jun 16, 2013, at 5:32 PM, John Blossom wrote: > Joseph, my thought is that we can have a Google+ Hangout a