Re: [OMPI users] Using PMI as RTE component

2014-05-15 Thread Ralph Castain
It's my fault - as release manager, I should have spotted that component sneaking into the release branch back in the 1.7 series, but I missed it. I have deleted it now as it was never intended to be released. Sorry for the confusion. Ralph On May 15, 2014, at 8:33 PM, Hadi Montakhabi wrote:

Re: [OMPI users] Using PMI as RTE component

2014-05-15 Thread Hadi Montakhabi
Ralph is right. I used 1.8, and after digging into it, I noticed it doesn't even compile the pmi component. When I tried to configure without orte, I could see the errors while compiling. It looks like it is well broken! Peace, Hadi On May 15, 2014 7:28 PM, "Ralph Castain" wrote: > Josh - he's t

Re: [OMPI users] Using PMI as RTE component

2014-05-15 Thread Ralph Castain
Josh - he's talking about the PMI component in ompi/mca/rte. It generally doesn't work. On May 15, 2014, at 5:15 PM, Joshua Ladd wrote: > Hadi, > > Is your job launching and executing normally? During the launch, frameworks > are initialized by opening all components, selecting the desired

Re: [OMPI users] Using PMI as RTE component

2014-05-15 Thread Joshua Ladd
Hadi, Is your job launching and executing normally? During the launch, frameworks are initialized by opening all components, selecting the desired one, and closing the others. I think you're just seeing components being opened, queried, and ultimately closed. The important thing is knowing if PMI

Re: [OMPI users] Using PMI as RTE component

2014-05-15 Thread Ralph Castain
I wouldn't trust that PMI component in the RTE framework - it was only created as a test example for that framework. It is routinely broken and not maintained, and can only be used if forced. Is this on the trunk? Or are you using the 1.8 series? If the latter, that component shouldn't even be

Re: [OMPI users] Using PMI as RTE component

2014-05-15 Thread Hadi Montakhabi
By "goes through orte component", I meant it does go into rte_orte_open function in rte_orte_component.c. Let me try to formulate my question in a different way: There are two components in the rte framework, namely orte and pmi. The question is whether pmi could be used independent from orte? Or i

Re: [OMPI users] Using PMI as RTE component

2014-05-15 Thread Ralph Castain
What do you mean "goes through orte component"? It will still call into the orte code base, but will use PMI to do the modex. On May 15, 2014, at 12:54 PM, Hadi Montakhabi wrote: > Hello, > > I am trying to utilize pmi instead of orte, but I come across the following > problem. > I do configu