Re: [Tagging] Route Relations and Special (Bannered) Routes

2012-03-11 Thread Nathan Edgars II
It's obvious to me that the "banner" is not part of the network. US 1 Alternate is part of the U.S. Highway system (US:US), not some mythical "U.S. Highway Alternate" system. It also makes the most sense to put it in the ref tag. Otherwise there's inconsistency between an alternate signed as U

Re: [Tagging] RFC - Bandstand

2012-03-11 Thread LM_1
2012/3/11 Johan Jönsson : > leisure=bandstand is a good tag. > The bandstand is a prominent feature that is easy to map, so ease of mapping > with one tag is prefect. > > With one tag it maps both: > *the physical building (band_stand says in one word that it is a small open > pavilion) > *the use/

Re: [Tagging] RFC - Bandstand

2012-03-11 Thread Johan Jönsson
leisure=bandstand is a good tag. The bandstand is a prominent feature that is easy to map, so ease of mapping with one tag is prefect. With one tag it maps both: *the physical building (band_stand says in one word that it is a small open pavilion) *the use/function: scheduled music (a bit inform

Re: [Tagging] A leisure tag for bathe

2012-03-11 Thread Johan Jönsson
I made a try to do go through some examples to see how it worked. They are at: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/User:Johan_J%C3%B6nsson/Workspace what I can see, it looks like it is only the open-air public nature bath locations that really lack tags, swimming_pools and indoor bath locations

[Tagging] RFC - Bandstand

2012-03-11 Thread Iggy spr
Hello, This is a proposal about tagging bandstands : http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Bandstand Any comments or suggestions are welcome. Regards, ___ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/lis

Re: [Tagging] A leisure tag for bathe

2012-03-11 Thread Johan Jönsson
In older days and in some parts of the world the public bath is an amenity and not a leisure. I am sticking to trying to find one tag for the leisure-bath establishments, but it might be possible to find a general tag encompassing both leisure and amenity and then have subtags to discern them. O

[Tagging] Route Relations and Special (Bannered) Routes

2012-03-11 Thread Phil! Gold
I'd like to solicit some thoughts on the tagging for special routes (commonly known as bannered routes)[0]. In route relations, it's customary to separate the network and the reference number. How do or should special routes fit into that? I'm torn between three views and I'm not sure which of t

Re: [Tagging] A leisure tag for bathe

2012-03-11 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
Am 10. März 2012 23:16 schrieb Johan Jönsson : > What do you think about a tag for different kind of places to bathe. > > Small recluse places along a river, > Organized public places with piers and beaches > Turkish bathes > maybe even hot springs. > > I´m thinking about something along the lines