For sure I would use Kamailio as an SBC, but nevertheless I see these
sortcoming in Kamailio (I don't know hov other SBCs handle this)
- config changes require a restart: most of the time this goes fast, but
sometimes processes may fail to start (ports not freed by the OS, ...).
Further, state
Hello,
I'm not going to comment on the relative merits of commercial products
like Net-Net SBC and ABC SBC, as this is an open source focused list
(we may continue this on kamailio-business if interested; of course
I'd also have a few things to say e.g. regarding HA, DOS or interop,
and we are mor
I'm curious re. your statement about P-CSCF. What does LI and transcoding
have to do with Kamailio? As already mentioned these functions are
available only in B2BUA which Kamailio is *not*. What other issues then did
you have with P-CSCF impl. using Kamailio. Also, how did P-CSCF even get
into this
Hi Melanie,
Now I'm curious about which tests are you mentioning. Also, Acme
Packet/Oracle as many different SBCs models, which can be selected
according with the customer's requirements.
When talking about the infinite number of features I wasn't really thinking
in H.323. Although, probably there
On 2/27/14 10:29 AM, Luis Silva wrote:
Don't understand how is it possible to compare Kamailio with the Acme Packet
SBC. Just to give an example, the DoS mechanism available on the AP SBC can't be
compared with any other solution available on the market. You will also have
HMRs, SIP Routing op
Vladimir-
> Transcoding can be supported in software as well.
Not at high capacity, like 20,000+ AMR-WB calls in a 1U server. My experience
has been that high volume users of SBC
products are SWaP constrained -- especially limited space and power
consumption. Their end customers do not allow
Hi,
As the maintainers of SEMS we fully agree with Carsten and Alex: the SBC
module of SEMS is a good replacement of a typical SBC. If one also is
looking for ease of usage, support, high availability and a powerful GUI
then the answer is the ABC SBC which is based on SEMS and the SBC
module. A fr
Hi Luis,
i wouldn't be too sure of that:
- HMR can be done with Text-Ops
- all the SIP-Routing options can be done by routing-logic (e.g. by
Route-Header, by Time of day, by method, ...)
The only thing missing here, is maybe acting as a B2BUA and proper
support for Session-Timers (which are end-t
Sorry ... I disagree at all All that features you mention, could be done
with kamalio ... BUT you have to work on your cfg to get them. You don't get
then out of the box.
Kamailio it's a powerfull tool ... It's not a final product as the AP Net SBC
Best regards
Luis Silva wrote:
>_
Don't understand how is it possible to compare Kamailio with the Acme
Packet SBC. Just to give an example, the DoS mechanism available on the AP
SBC can't be compared with any other solution available on the market. You
will also have HMRs, SIP Routing options out-of-the-box (like time of the
day r
On 27 Feb 2014, at 07:29, Alex Balashov wrote:
> No howto for that, and more than there is a howto for developing a messenger
> and selling it to Facebook for $20bn.
Damn. I can stop googling now then.
/O :-)
___
SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamaili
LCR has complex business rules and usually requires at least some third party
integration or development. No howto for that, and more than there is a howto
for developing a messenger and selling it to Facebook for $20bn.
Melanie Pietersen wrote:
>looking at this, is there some howto for settin
looking at this, is there some howto for setting up high-availability,
LCR and route-by-route transcoding?
Melanie
On 2/20/14 7:12 PM, Carsten Bock wrote:
Hi Francesco,
i would recommend, you look at the SEMS-project and it's SBC module.
From the functionality perspective, i don't think you'l
Hi Francesco,
o Carsten Bock on 02/21/2014 12:05 AM:
> Hi Francesco,
>
> Yes, SEMS is well maintained (i don't know, how well the website is
> maintained).
>
> You find the souce-code here:
> http://git.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/gitweb.cgi?p=sems;a=summary
Carsten is right that SEMS is maintained,
On 2/20/14, 6:25 PM, Francesco Maria Magnini wrote:
Fred,
in you ACME replacement, kamailio doesn’t rewrite headers for handling
RTP/SIGNALING and stay in the middle?
For nat it did. For others the media server did.
You can easily force all connections to use rtpproxy to do what you ask.
We
Fred,
in you ACME replacement, kamailio doesn’t rewrite headers for handling
RTP/SIGNALING and stay in the middle?
Il giorno 21/feb/2014, alle ore 00:03, Fred Posner ha scritto:
> On 2/20/14, 5:55 PM, Francesco Maria Magnini wrote:
>> @Carsten
>> I looked at http://www.iptel.org/sems and seems
Hi Francesco,
Yes, SEMS is well maintained (i don't know, how well the website is
maintained).
You find the souce-code here:
http://git.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/gitweb.cgi?p=sems;a=summary
Kind regards,
Carsten
Am 20.02.2014 23:55 schrieb "Francesco Maria Magnini" :
> @Carsten
> I looked at http:
On 2/20/14, 5:55 PM, Francesco Maria Magnini wrote:
@Carsten
I looked at http://www.iptel.org/sems and seems to be only broken links to
downloads.
Do you know if the project is still maintained?
@Fred
Are you using openser as a B2BUA?
No, because of course Kamailio is not a b2bua. =)
In the
You don't need B2B functionality to provide SBC functionality.
SBC is a loose term these days. All you need is properly crafted signaling
to achieve you requirements.
Using a SIP proxy server as an SBC is pretty common these days.
Regards
Ovidiu Sas
On Feb 20, 2014 5:55 PM, "Francesco Maria Magnin
@Carsten
I looked at http://www.iptel.org/sems and seems to be only broken links to
downloads.
Do you know if the project is still maintained?
@Fred
Are you using openser as a B2BUA?
Il giorno 20/feb/2014, alle ore 19:42, Fred Posner ha scritto:
> Alex's article is one of my favorites. That be
Alex's article is one of my favorites. That being said, we switched out
an Acme SBC for openser (at the time) and was immediately thrilled.
Fred Posner
The Palner Group, Inc.
503-914-0999 (direct)
954-472-2896 (fax)
On 02/20/2014 01:14 PM, Alex Balashov wrote:
Francesco,
Have a look at this b
Francesco,
Have a look at this blog post:
http://www.likewise.am/2013/03/kamailio-as-an-sbc-session-border-controller/
That said, I agree with Carsten's suggestion of SEMS.
On 02/20/2014 11:04 AM, Francesco Maria Magnini wrote:
Hi,
I would like to have some suggestions about a full replacem
Hi Francesco,
i would recommend, you look at the SEMS-project and it's SBC module.
>From the functionality perspective, i don't think you'll miss anything
compared to Acme Packet, latest trunk version even has a Registration
cache, which works absolutely great...
Kind regards,
Carsten
2014-02-20
23 matches
Mail list logo
