Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02

2024-10-23 Thread tom petch
Petch From: linchangwang Sent: 22 October 2024 01:08 To: tom petch; Greg Mirsky Cc: RTGWG; rtgwg-chairs Subject: Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02 Hi Tom, Greg, Thank you for your valuable feedback. We will

Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02

2024-10-21 Thread linchangwang
reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02 From: Greg Mirsky Sent: 20 October 2024 22:40 Hi Tom, thank you for your help in clarifying the scope of the draft. Please find several notes below tagged GIM>> (not on the proposed mechanism but rather on the general aspe

Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02

2024-10-21 Thread tom petch
From: Greg Mirsky Sent: 20 October 2024 22:40 Hi Tom, thank you for your help in clarifying the scope of the draft. Please find several notes below tagged GIM>> (not on the proposed mechanism but rather on the general aspects of protection and redundancy). Weelll if you look you will see that

Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02

2024-10-21 Thread tom petch
From: Greg Mirsky Sent: 20 October 2024 22:40 Hi Tom, thank you for your help in clarifying the scope of the draft. Please find several notes below tagged GIM>> (not on the proposed mechanism but rather on the general aspects of protection and redundancy). Weelll if you look you will see that

Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02

2024-10-21 Thread tom petch
From: Greg Mirsky Sent: 20 October 2024 22:40 Hi Tom, thank you for your help in clarifying the scope of the draft. Please find several notes below tagged GIM>> (not on the proposed mechanism but rather on the general aspects of protection and redundancy). Weelll if you look you will see that

Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02

2024-10-20 Thread Greg Mirsky
Hi Tom, thank you for your help in clarifying the scope of the draft. Please find several notes below tagged GIM>> (not on the proposed mechanism but rather on the general aspects of protection and redundancy). Regards, Greg On Sun, Oct 20, 2024 at 2:14 AM tom petch wrote: > Abstract is too sho

Re: Request for MORE reviews of draft-liu-rtgwg-path-aware-remote-protection-02

2024-10-20 Thread tom petch
Abstract is too short - it fails to tell me whether or not I want to read further. Perhaps Current IP network protection mechanisms can be divided into local protection and end-to-end protection. Local protection technologies, such as ECMP and TI-LFA, can only detect local failures and