rsync - detecting change/no-change without an itemised list

2015-11-18 Thread Robert Bell
rsync watchers, I've been using rsync version 3.1.1+, and do like the improved --stats output: e.g. Number of files: 2480403 (reg: 2034290, dir: 233487, link: 212174, special: 452) Number of created files: 356 (reg: 6, dir: 3, link: 347) Number of regular files transferred: 16 ... - thanks to

[Bug 11523] New: Request: Add option to unlink hard links when permissions change

2015-09-20 Thread Robert Bell
Folks, b...@stupidkitties.com wrote: " I was wondering if it'd be feasible to add an option (or multiple options, depending on the desired granularity) to cause rsync to treat changes in file attributes the same way it treats changes to the file's contents when it encounters hard links at the des

Recycling directories and backup performance. Was: Re: rsync --link-dest won't link even if existing file is out of date (fwd)

2015-04-15 Thread Robert Bell
rsync folks, Henri Shustak wrote: LBackup always starts a new backup snapshot with an empty directory. I have been looking at extending --link-dest options to scan beyond just the previous successful backup to (failed backups / older backups). However, there are all kinds of edge cases which ar

Patch for rsync --link-dest won't link even if existing file is out of date (fwd)

2015-04-06 Thread Robert Bell
Folks, We faced a similar situation to that which Ken described - we recycle backup directories, for good reason. There is a patch to solve the problem. Our systems administrator provided the following description of the patches we use: ==

Recycling and keeping backups - Tower of Hanoi management of backups using rsync

2014-09-15 Thread Robert Bell
Thanks to Kevin and Paul for responses. We use a modified Tower of Hanoi scheme (on top of rsync and --link-dest and recycling) for deciding which backups to keep. Here is a sample of our holdings for one area: home.2024.seq.0 set 0 home.20130512.seq.512 set 10 h

Re: Backup scripts - recycling old backup directories (Kevin Korb)

2014-09-14 Thread Robert Bell
Kevin, Thanks for the reply and interest in this topic. Comments below. Regards Rob. I did consider that but rejected it for 2 reasons... 1. Backup run time. We have a 4 hour window to run backups at night. Using recycled directories significantly extended the backup run time. The deleti

Backup scripts - recycling old backup directories

2014-09-11 Thread Robert Bell
Folks, Kevin Korb wrote: Have you considered more advanced methods such as subvolume snapshots provided by ZFS and BTRFS? At work we were forced to abandon rsync - --link-dest because of the amount of time it takes to delete old backups when the data is primarily many millions of small files (s

[Bug 10738] New: report --stats output when termination signal arrives (fwd)

2014-07-24 Thread Robert Bell
Folks, I would find the output of -stats information to be useful when rsync fails. Typically, we use rsync to do backups, and if an rsync fails, we'd like to know how much data has been transferred in the failed run, to report on our internal web page for the backups, and to make estimates of h

Changed attributes for a file in destination that is hard linked get propagated to --link-dest directories

2013-01-22 Thread Robert Bell
Folks, Thinking again about the issue of changed attributes for a file in source that is identical in content to a file in destination that is hard linked get propagated to the --link-dest directories I would like to suggest a new flag, (perhaps called something like --preserve-linked-at

Re: rsync - using a --files-from list to cut out scanning. How to handle deletions? (fwd)B

2013-01-21 Thread Robert Bell
Paul Wayne, Kevin, Teodor and others, Thanks for your contributions in response to my postings. Paul: I was very imprecise if not plain wrong in my description. :-( Thanks for explaining what really happens. "Rsync will not update an existing file in-place unless you use the --inplace option.

Re: rsync - using a --files-from list to cut out scanning. How to handle deletions? (fwd)

2013-01-17 Thread Robert Bell
Kevin, Thanks for your response. Some observations are inter-lined below. Rob. Regards Rob. Bell e-mail: robert.b...@csiro.au -- Dr Robert C. Bell, BSc (Hons) PhD Technical Services Manager Advanced Scientific Computing CSIRO IM&T Phone: +61 3 9669 8102 | Mobile: +61 428 108 333

rsync - using a --files-from list to cut out scanning. How to handle deletions?

2013-01-14 Thread Robert Bell
Folks, We use rsync extensively for protecting data by making backups. Thank you to the authors and maintainers. Like many others, we use the --link-dest option to cut down on the space occupied by the backups. Unlike many others, we re-cycle old backup directories. Since most file systems

Re: rsync Digest, Vol 116, Issue 19

2012-09-06 Thread Robert Bell
Wayne, Thanks for the information - that looks useful for the future, and would replace our option. Rob. Date: Fri, 24 Aug 2012 23:10:43 -0700 From: Wayne Davison To: Robert Bell Cc: rsync@lists.samba.org Subject: Re: [patch] link-dest messages and max-size warnings (fwd) On Thu, Aug 23

[patch] link-dest messages and max-size warnings (fwd)

2012-08-23 Thread Robert Bell
rsync Folks, The following explanatory text is by me and the patches are by Rowan McKenzie for use by the Advanced Scientific Computing group at CSIRO. This patch builds upon the --link-dest patch by Bryant Hansen (Thanks heaps!). 1. The original patch provided an alternate behaviour for rsync

Re: rsync Digest, Vol 83, Issue 12

2009-11-17 Thread Robert Bell
Dear rsync folks, Re the recent discussion of: Subject: RE: Does files-from work with --delete? We have come across the same issue, in doing partial backups of a file system and using the --files-from and --link-dest feature to a re-cycled area. Files that should be deleted tend to build up.

Re: rsync --link-dest option with the destination directory containing old files.

2008-12-22 Thread Robert Bell
avison To: Robert Bell Cc: rsync@lists.samba.org Subject: Re: rsync --link-dest option with the destination directory containing old files. Resent-Date: Tue, 23 Dec 2008 15:56:17 +1100 (EST) Resent-From: On Tue, Dec 23, 2008 at 10:22:42AM +1100, Robert Bell wrote: we would like rsync to

rsync --link-dest option with the destination directory containing old files.

2008-12-22 Thread Robert Bell
Way back: > -- Forwarded message -- Date: Mon, 2 Jun 2003 > 09:56:50 -0700 (PDT) From: Michael Rubel galcit.caltech.edu> To: rsync at lists.samba.org Subject: > --link-dest when target and compare_dir both have file > > Hi J.W. et al, > > Kevin Everets was kind enough to inform