Re: Cagliotti and Other Issues

2009-03-23 Thread Alan Hewat
> According to the ccp14 news site the wiki (I guess from apparent lack > of interest) was recently deactivated after a ccp14 web server upgrade. In practice, people use whatever is available in the refinement programs (sometimes blindly :-) The authors of those programs have already spent conside

Re: Cagliotti and Other Issues

2009-03-23 Thread Vincent Favre-Nicolin
Hi, > I wonder if we should, as a community, put some of this stuff on > wikipedia, or another such place. In other words, distill the > community's collective knowledge in a single place that can be updated > in the future, and also curated for correctness also by the community. > What a

Re: Cagliotti and Other Issues

2009-03-23 Thread Leonid Solovyov
2/09, Simon Billinge wrote: > From: Simon Billinge > Subject: Cagliotti and Other Issues > To: "rietveld_l" > Date: Sunday, March 22, 2009, 8:50 PM > Dear Rietvelders > > What is the most complete and authoritative source for > issues such as > profile fu

RE: Cagliotti and Other Issues

2009-03-22 Thread Davor Balzar
Wikipedia or perhaps publish a paper... :-) Davor > -Original Message- > From: simon.billi...@gmail.com > [mailto:simon.billi...@gmail.com] On Behalf Of Simon Billinge > Sent: Sunday, March 22, 2009 2:50 PM > To: rietveld_l > Subject: Cagliotti and Other Issues > >

RE: Cagliotti and Other Issues

2009-03-22 Thread Matthew.Rowles
-Original Message- From: May, Frank [mailto:frank.l@umsl.edu] >My recollection is the Cagliotti function was adapted to the x-ray case when >we had low resolution x-ray instruments and slow (or no) computers. Now that >we have high resolution instruments and fast computers, why d

Cagliotti and Other Issues

2009-03-22 Thread Simon Billinge
Dear Rietvelders What is the most complete and authoritative source for issues such as profile function definitions, what is their scientific basis, and when are they appropriate to use, etc.? I am guessing there is not one-stop-shop solution (Young's book? GSAS manual? Rietveld list archive?

Cagliotti and Other Issues

2009-03-20 Thread May, Frank
Back to basics and First Principles As Alan says, the [use of the Cagliotti function is appropriate for the neutron case], "but not really for X-ray and other geometries." My recollection is the Cagliotti function was adapted to the x-ray case when we had low resolution x-ray instruments