Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-11-02 Thread Anne Paulson
Can someone who uses the full bikepacking setup tell me how much it holds? Assuming that the frame bag holds the food, I'm having trouble understanding how a tent (let's say the Hubba), a sleeping bag, a pad and some rainclothes and other extra clothes, plus phone and tools and things like that, ca

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-11-02 Thread Dan Abelson
I have a relevate tangle bag and a revelate mountain feed bag. I like them both a lot. They are well made, well thought out and work great. Dan Abelson St. Paul, MN On Sat, Nov 2, 2013 at 4:00 PM, Mike Schiller wrote: > s24o in a snow cave Done that a few times for fun... also sleep > outs

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-11-01 Thread Deacon Patrick
I hike-a-bike quite a bit, with the large SaddleSack and sometimes with the TourSacks under it. Neither has been an issue for me. With abandon, Patrick On Friday, November 1, 2013 4:53:11 PM UTC-6, Anne Paulson wrote: > > Thanks, everybody, for your excellent, thought-provoking posts and > link

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-11-01 Thread Anne Paulson
Thanks, everybody, for your excellent, thought-provoking posts and links. Whoever mentioned those super-big 3" tires for off-road, yeah. The Krampus and the ECR look so cool. One thing I hadn't appreciated about the Revelate-style bags is that saddlebags that aren't any wider than me are not going

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-10-31 Thread Tim McNamara
On Oct 31, 2013, at 8:20 PM, Mike Schiller wrote: > > I'm with Garth, I prefer my Revelate seat bag to any of the Carradice > saddlebags. They are lighter, don't sway and are great for compressing your > gear. Also. on rugged terrain, you are often pushing your bike, which can be > a hassle w

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-10-31 Thread Garth
FWIW .. I don't consider the Nelson and others like it "common", so my comment was not speaking to those Anne ;) I'm speaking of the common bags you find most widely distributed in bike shops and online retailers and such. To a Riv owner, yes they are ... but outside of this comparatively s

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-10-31 Thread Joe Broach
Hi Anne, Interesting observations. I've been happy with my old Baggins Hoss but not too thrilled with my Carradice Camper (purchased in 2010). The leather straps on the latter are poor quality and started cracking almost immediately. The hardware is cheap with sharp edges. It's currently out of co

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-10-31 Thread Deacon Patrick
If you're gonna take marketing personally you're in for a wild ride. Grin. With abandon, Patrick On Thursday, October 31, 2013 4:11:53 PM UTC-6, Anne Paulson wrote: > > "The nylon used is heavy duty and top notch,and very very well thought > out, unlike your common saddlebag." > > I don't doub

Re: [RBW] Re: Saddlebags vs Revelate bags

2013-10-31 Thread Anne Paulson
"The nylon used is heavy duty and top notch,and very very well thought out, unlike your common saddlebag." I don't doubt that the Revelate bags are thought out, but I take exception to the idea that other saddlebags are not well thought out. I have both a Nelson Longflap and the splendid Rivendel