Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2014-01-09 Thread Chris Lampe 2
When I had my old Trek Multitrack re-fitted with a threadless fork it took two phone calls and a personal visit to the shop to convince them not to cut the steerer tube! I told them to stack the spacers and put the stem at the very top (so I'd have plenty of cable length). I'll admit it looke

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2014-01-09 Thread Chris Lampe 2
Shaun, Based on my experience and research, I love the design of the Atlantis. However, it's a pricey option so I'm considering a LHT instead. The only thing about the Trucker that concerns me is the chainstay length of 46cm (compared to the 44cm chainstays of the Atlantis). You've ridden b

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-08-01 Thread Shaun Meehan
I've got a 64cm LHT that replaced a 68cm Atlantis. There is probably 1 or 2 more cm of seatpost showing on the Trucker but I feel more comfortable on it. With spacers on the steerer the vertical relationship beween the saddle and the bars is the same as on the Atlantis (bars slightly higher than sa

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-08-01 Thread Matt Beebe
Hi Jim, I measured a 58 and and a 62, though my measurements may have been off by half a centimeter give or take.The 58 seems to have a 61cm actual TT length, and the 62 has a 63cm actual TT length.Doing some trigonometry the 58 Hunq has about a 63cm effective TT and the 62 has about a

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-08-01 Thread James Warren
The following frames do not have expanded geometry: Atlantis, AHH, Roadeo. The following do: Hillborne, Hunqapillar, Bombadil, San Marcos, Betty Foy The expanded ones are identified in the chart by their 6 degree toptube slope (if they have a TT.) Any in that category should be showing just effe

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-08-01 Thread Matt Beebe
It's not actually clear which frames on the current geometry chart show the effective rather than actual TT lengths. I know for example that the Hunqapillar TT lengths listed are definitely not effective length though, I don't even think they are actual length. Matt On Thursday, August 1

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-31 Thread James Warren
To David Craig's question: no, for Atlantis and AHH, the TT listings are actual, not effective. So with those two, the effective TT is a bit longer, but the effect is relatively small due to low angles. But yes it's true that the expanded frames (6 degree upslope ones) only list the effective

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-31 Thread James Warren
For that matter, in the industry in general why are so few TT upslope angles included in geometry info? With Rivs, for example, it's important to know that some models slope about 2 degrees, while others slope 6 degrees. The 6 degree ones shoot those bars up about 4 extra centimeters relative t

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-31 Thread cyclotourist
Query: Why do most manufacturers use the C-T measurement, when the "top" is sorta' ambiguous? Seems like C-C is a more consistent measurement, and the way top tubes are measured as well. Juster wondering. On 7/31/13, David Craig wrote: > Point taken, Matt. > > On the topic of tt's, I seem to reca

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-31 Thread Brewster Fong
On Wednesday, July 31, 2013 12:16:04 PM UTC-7, meehan...@gmail.com wrote: > > A friend of mine recently purchased a Long Haul Trucker from his LBS in > Wisconsin after coming up and test riding both my LHT and my Ogre to > decide which one he wanted to get. > > When the shop took delivery o

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-31 Thread Shaun Meehan
A friend of mine recently purchased a Long Haul Trucker from his LBS in Wisconsin after coming up and test riding both my LHT and my Ogre to decide which one he wanted to get. When the shop took delivery of the bike, my friend called me asking for my advice as to what height he should have his ste

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-31 Thread Ron Mc
my sister and BIL have new bikes from REI. Her power is not falling off. On Wednesday, July 31, 2013 6:50:30 AM UTC-5, Ron Mc wrote: > > I've never met a mean guy in a bike shop. Mostly passionate people, some > jaded people who've heard it all before. This works for me and it should > wor

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-31 Thread Ron Mc
I've never met a mean guy in a bike shop. Mostly passionate people, some jaded people who've heard it all before. This works for me and it should work for you, too, is a natural attitude. I think the comfort aspect that is so important to us, um, older guys really is lost in bike shops and c

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread IanA
Excellent points made. I hope that I positively influenced the purchase of the bike. Only time will (may?) tell. After the positive and thoughtful comments from all listers on this thread, I might have been a lot more circumspect in helping my friend. Perhaps I would have just presented opi

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread hsmitham
David, Wow! Kudos to you. You just saved me a a lot of typing. Everything, everything you just stated I agree with. Extremely well said. Advertisers, use the notion that we make decisions based on emotion and we rectify those decisions by believing we came to those decisions by way of rationa

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread David Craig
"Lets not have this degrade into something where people have to justify to whoever that they use what they buy or "deserve" to own something." Yep, I agree 100%. I'm truly sorry if I offended anyone. I have nothin' against hatchet buyers or sellers, would-be woodspeople in Walnut Creek, or anyb

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread Peter Morgano
Lets not have this degrade into something where people have to justify to whoever that they use what they buy or "deserve" to own something. I buy stuff because I like it, what I do or don't do with it is my own business. I might buy that hatchet and just hang it on a wall for the next 20 years bec

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread Liesl
I do, though, use my Gransfors-Bruk Mini Hatchet. ;) -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to rbw-owners-bunch+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To post

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread David Craig
It's tough to fit a bike. Really, it's much tougher than I think it seems to many of us. It's way tougher than selling shoes and even that isn't straightforward. Can we give well-intentioned shop owners, manufacturers and bike shop kids the benefit of the doubt? That doesn't mean we should blin

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread Ron Mc
in a perfect world, we'd all have custom-made frames with top tubes and seat tubes made just for us. Most of us can't. My buddy and I are both 6'3", but my legs are 5" longer than his, and his torso is 5" longer than mine. He rides a 59cm and needs a long top tube, I ride a 64cm and need a s

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-30 Thread stevef
Surly measures center to top, but the seat tube extends past the toptube a bit. You can kindof see what I mean in this geometry diagram: http://surlybikes.com/bikes/cross_check_ss/geometry Pre-cutting a steel steerer (unlike a carbon fiber one that has a maximum recommended number of spacers f

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-28 Thread Cyclofiend Jim
Couple o' points - - Yeah, I do think that a lot of large-scale manufacturers send the bikes with shorter steerers. Forks and frames don't necessarily come from the same production facility, and they are often cut to spec before packaging them. - Grant's fitting guidelines are ostensibly for

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-28 Thread Eric Daume
I think Surly ships most bikes with the steerer cut. The LHT comes uncut, supposedly. Eric On Sun, Jul 28, 2013 at 8:35 AM, bobish wrote: > > The only thing I'd fault the shop on is cutting the steerer tube before > selling the bike. > > This! I'm sorry but the only way to explain this (pre-fit

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-28 Thread cyclotourist
Seems silly to cut down all those steerers. But I am impressed that a bike shop carries multiple sizes of Cross Checks on the floor. That's pretty cool in and of itself. On 7/28/13, bobish wrote: >> The only thing I'd fault the shop on is cutting the steerer tube before >> selling the bike. > >

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-28 Thread bobish
> The only thing I'd fault the shop on is cutting the steerer tube before > selling the bike. This! I'm sorry but the only way to explain this (pre-fitting) is stupid, lazy or both. • Perry -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-27 Thread IanA
An excellent point about the measurement system. The CC SS comes with flat bars with a bit of a backwards sweep, so maybe the longer top tube was what my friend found so comfortable. Curiously, the store was of the opinion that if you have drops, then a longer top tube is better so you can "ge

Re: [RBW] Re: Bike Fitting - A Mine Field

2013-07-27 Thread Eric Platt
Actually, it sounds to me like everyone knew what they were doing. I've owned a number of Surly bikes over the years. The first one, a Cross Check, was 62cm. Realized after about 2 months I'd never get comfortable with the handlebars so far away. Ended up putting Albatross bars on that bike and