Re: SPAM: [Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Jason Edgecombe
On 01/04/2014 08:46 AM, Jason Antman wrote: After digressing into this discussion on #puppet last night, I was wondering what the community feelings are on ENCs vs Hiera... I know that Dashboard/Console still exists, but have heard rumors (for years) of it being either replaced by something else

Re: [Puppet Users] Permissions for Windows Files Sourced from Puppet Master

2014-01-04 Thread Jeff Bachtel
+1 I would not be at odds, it seems like that is a sensible default behavior, while still preserving the ability to shoot one's self in the foot if needs be. Jeff On 11/20/2013 01:40 PM, Rob Reynolds wrote: With the changes for http://projects.puppetlabs.com/issues/18931 (Don't set mode on

[Puppet Users] Re: Permissions for Windows Files Sourced from Puppet Master

2014-01-04 Thread Igor Berger
I think "ignore" is the correct default on Windows, assuming it results in files / directories that inherit permissions of their parents. On Friday, January 3, 2014 11:53:22 PM UTC-5, Rob Reynolds wrote: > > Folks supporting Windows, do you have an opinion with this warning? This > may have got

Re: [Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Jose Luis Ledesma
Enforcing environment from the master is a must for us, and I don't really see the point of configuring hiera against LDAP when puppet supports it natively. Do you know some benefit I'm missing? -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Puppet Users" group.

Re: [Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Jason Slagle
On 01/04/2014 01:15 PM, Jose Luis Ledesma wrote: I'm in the process of setting up puppet in my company and I don't like at all the idea of having some thousand of files for describe the nodes. And, despite the well known limitations, I like a lot the idea of having an enc like ldap. So use

Re: [Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Jose Luis Ledesma
I'm in the process of setting up puppet in my company and I don't like at all the idea of having some thousand of files for describe the nodes. And, despite the well known limitations, I like a lot the idea of having an enc like ldap. Regards, -- You received this message because you are subs

Re: [Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Jose Luis Ledesma
I'm in the process of setting up puppet in my company and I don't like at all the idea of having some thousand of files for describe the nodes. And, despite the well known limitations, I like a lot the idea of having an enc like ldap. Regards, -- You received this message because you are subs

Re: [Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Jason Antman
I guess I hit a bit of a nomenclature issue here. By "ENC" I didn't just mean the node_terminus script, but the whole app - i.e. "ENC" as in the way Dashboard is an ENC... Though your comment does remind me that Hiera can now be more than "a directory full of YAML files"... I guess I'll start doin

Re: [Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Peter Meier
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 > But as I'm starting down the road of writing *another* ENC - > hopefully "a good one" this time - and more and more people whose > advice and knowledge I've respected for years say "use Hiera", I'm > starting to wonder if either (a) I'm totally missi

[Puppet Users] The Future - ENCs vs Hiera?

2014-01-04 Thread Jason Antman
After digressing into this discussion on #puppet last night, I was wondering what the community feelings are on ENCs vs Hiera... I know that Dashboard/Console still exists, but have heard rumors (for years) of it being either replaced by something else, or totally rewritten. Then there's Foreman,

Re: [Puppet Users] ENC in Nodejs Error

2014-01-04 Thread Jason Antman
I *think* that "Empty response" is the issue here... your script appears to be sending back YAML with just an (empty) classes hash and an (empty) parameters hash. Try putting something in parameters (at least). Also make sure that it's actually writing to STDOUT, not STDERR. Assuming neither of th

Re: [Puppet Users] Re: wondering if I want to much now.

2014-01-04 Thread Jason Antman
This is one of the best descriptions of how to do things in Puppet (or maybe how not to) that I've seen, and touches on a *lot* of common misunderstandings. I think I might have to keep a short url to the archive of this handy... Thanks, John. On 01/03/2014 10:35 AM, jcbollinger wrote: > > > On