Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-08-13 Thread Adam Armstrong
On 28/07/2010 15:17, Tony Finch wrote: On Tue, 27 Jul 2010, Joe Greco wrote: Weren't the FCC and at&t recently suggesting that VoIP was the future of telephony? BT are currently upgrading the UK's phone system to VOIP. But it's running on a private network. Aren't BT still failing to trust

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-31 Thread Joe Abley
On 2010-07-30, at 07:59, Marshall Eubanks wrote: > Hmm. Looks like an RFC, but isn't. Do you know if there are any plans to > actually publish this ? The authoritative and current ICANN DPS is published here: https://www.iana.org/dnssec/ My understanding is that the current copyright and th

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Marshall Eubanks
On Jul 30, 2010, at 12:55 AM, James Hess wrote: On Thu, Jul 29, 2010 at 10:23 PM, Franck Martin wrote: Hmmm, from the interview of the British guy, the smart card seems to be in UK (he did a lapsus on it), which differs from what you describe. You gotta read up on the whole ceremony and

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Sean Donelan
On Fri, 30 Jul 2010, Joe Abley wrote: One observation from a non-crypto operations guy that was drawn into this project and has learnt a lot from having to implement the infrastructure designed by real crypto people: security is not always obvious. What seems like a flaw is often not, and what

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread James Hess
On Thu, Jul 29, 2010 at 10:23 PM, Franck Martin wrote: > Hmmm, from the interview of the British guy, the smart card seems to be in UK > (he did a lapsus on it), which differs from what you describe. You gotta read up on the whole ceremony and their statement of practices: https://www.iana.o

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Franck Martin
- Original Message - > From: "Doug Barton" > To: "Franck Martin" > Cc: "Joe Abley" , nanog@nanog.org > Sent: Friday, 30 July, 2010 3:49:04 PM > Subject: Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet > On 07/29

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Doug Barton
On 07/29/10 20:09, valdis.kletni...@vt.edu wrote: > On Thu, 29 Jul 2010 20:19:45 CDT, Jorge Amodio said: > >> I suggest that it should be seriously considered to revoke the role of >> RKSH from the person that used that role to obtain publicity and self >> promotion, and request the immediate retu

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Doug Barton
On 07/29/10 20:23, Franck Martin wrote: > I should read the spec Yes, preferably before commenting on it publicly ... Doug (... oops) -- Improve the effectiveness of your Internet presence with a domain name makeover!http://SupersetSolutions.com/ Computers are

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Jorge Amodio
> A pretty good article that puts a lot of the rest of it back into perspective: > > http://www.digitalsociety.org/2010/07/fantasy-role-playing-has-no-place-in-dnssec Good article indeed. It is highly unlikely that we will ever need the service of the RKSH, I agree that a well know public figure

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Franck Martin
Subject: Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet On 2010-07-28, at 18:24, andrew.wallace wrote: > I think there is a social vulnerability in a group of people who need to > travel, > a lot of the time, by plane, to exactly the same location to make new keys to > r

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Thu, 29 Jul 2010 20:19:45 CDT, Jorge Amodio said: > I suggest that it should be seriously considered to revoke the role of > RKSH from the person that used that role to obtain publicity and self > promotion, and request the immediate return of all cryptographic > material. This is not something

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Jorge Amodio
> By publicising the list of crypto officers ICANN aims to increase > transparency in the normal process (no drills required). We have no reason to > think that our last-resort options will ever be exercised, but we have > planned for them nonetheless because this is an important system and all

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Joe Abley
On 2010-07-28, at 18:24, andrew.wallace wrote: > I think there is a social vulnerability in a group of people who need to > travel, > a lot of the time, by plane, to exactly the same location to make new keys to > reset DNSSEC. Let's try to forget this "reset DNSSEC" meme. This is a technical

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-29 Thread Jorge Amodio
The story keeps growing out of proportion and in the wrong direction ... This one claims that "six" guys hold the keys to bring back porn : http://indyposted.com/34983/six-guys-have-the-keys-to-the-internet/comment-page-1/#comment-15785 And ABC is talking about the "brotherhood" : http://abcnew

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread todd glassey
On 7/28/2010 1:16 PM, Jorge Amodio wrote: >>> Also, these famous guys selected as part of the TCR group where the >>> number is not actually seven, don't even have enough material to sign >>> anything by themselves. >> Of course not. The only real requirement is that the TCR group hold enough >>

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Jorge Amodio
>> Also, these famous guys selected as part of the TCR group where the >> number is not actually seven, don't even have enough material to sign >> anything by themselves. > > Of course not.  The only real requirement is that the TCR group hold enough > shares so ICANN can't sign anything without th

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 14:20:51 CDT, Jorge Amodio said: > Also, these famous guys selected as part of the TCR group where the > number is not actually seven, don't even have enough material to sign > anything by themselves. Of course not. The only real requirement is that the TCR group hold enough

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Jorge Amodio
> Obviously you have approximately zero understanding of the crypto community. > They tend to be the most paranoid people out there - and the *only* way to get > acceptance of a signed root was to make sure that ICANN is *not* in posession > of enough keying material to sign a key by itself.  In ad

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 09:24:57 PDT, "andrew.wallace" said: > What I think is, this is leaving them wide open to attack. If an attack was > state-sponsored, its likely they would be able to stop those selected people > reaching the location in the United States by way of operational officers > inte

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Jorge Amodio
> Of course this is just my opinion. Which is totally unfounded and equivalent to a ton of dung. Please stop with the non-operational content conspiracy theories, tnx.

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread andrew.wallace
On Wed, Jul 28, 2010 at 9:33 AM, Elmar K. Bins wrote: > andrew.wall...@rocketmail.com (andrew.wallace) wrote: > >> A British computer expert has been entrusted with part of a digital key, to >>help >> restart the internet in the event of a major catastrophe. >> >> >> Paul Kane talked to Eddie M

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Tony Finch
On Wed, 28 Jul 2010, Leen Besselink wrote: > > If you think that is misleading, you would want to see this article: > > http://www.metro.co.uk/news/836210-brit-given-a-key-to-unlock-the-internet See also the press releases from Bath University: http://www.bath.ac.uk/news/2010/07/26/internet-secur

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Tony Finch
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010, Joe Greco wrote: > > Weren't the FCC and at&t recently suggesting that VoIP was the future of > telephony? BT are currently upgrading the UK's phone system to VOIP. But it's running on a private network. Tony. -- f.anthony.n.finchhttp://dotat.at/ SOUTH FITZROY: NORTHEAST

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread gordon b slater
On Wed, 2010-07-28 at 10:33 +0200, Elmar K. Bins wrote: > One, I do not see the operational relevance of this "news". The real problem is that articles like this DO get considerable attention in the UK - a place where "the internet" has yet to gain true understanding and recognition as a national

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Elmar K. Bins
andrew.wall...@rocketmail.com (andrew.wallace) wrote: > A British computer expert has been entrusted with part of a digital key, to > help > restart the internet in the event of a major catastrophe. > >   > Paul Kane talked to Eddie Mair on Radio 4's PM programme about what he might > be > c

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Paul Thornton
Leen Besselink wrote: > On 07/28/2010 02:21 AM, valdis.kletni...@vt.edu wrote: >> >> That plus the phrase "restarting the Internet" is more than a little bit >> misleading. >> >> > > If you think that is misleading, you would want to see this article: > > http://www.metro.co.uk/news/836210-br

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Leen Besselink
On 07/28/2010 02:21 AM, valdis.kletni...@vt.edu wrote: That plus the phrase "restarting the Internet" is more than a little bit misleading. If you think that is misleading, you would want to see this article: http://www.metro.co.uk/news/836210-brit-given-a-key-to-unlock-the-internet By

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-28 Thread Matthew Walster
On 28 July 2010 04:52, Joe Greco wrote: > Right, I think I pointed out it was basically SMS, despite being billed > as "enterprise paging," which brings us back to the previous question > > Or are you saying that there are SMS networks out there that aren't part > of the cellular network?  :-)

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Joe Greco
> On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 21:37:57 -0400, Joe Greco wrote: > > Relatively speaking, at&t's Enterprise Paging (which appears to just be > > enterprise SMS with a TAP/SNPP gateway) has been a lot more reliable. I > > have no idea how reliable it'd be in a major telecom crisis, of course. > > I'd expec

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Ricky Beam
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 21:21:56 -0400, Jim Richardson wrote: That's already a problem for getting alert pages. Any actual *pager* companies left? They all seem to have gone to SMS systems. SkyTel is the only one I remember. Sadly, their coverage is about that of Cricket or Clearwire. (at leas

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 20:37:57 CDT, Joe Greco said: > Aren't there still some satellite pager providers out there? :-) Works fine till solar flare season. :) pgpInyHorwObH.pgp Description: PGP signature

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Joe Greco
> On Tue, Jul 27, 2010 at 5:38 PM, Joe Greco wrote: > > As wonderful as the new communications paradigms are, do we also > > have a situation now developing where it might eventually become > > very difficult or even impossible to ensure out-of-band lines of > > communications remain available? >

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Jim Richardson
On Tue, Jul 27, 2010 at 5:38 PM, Joe Greco wrote: > > As wonderful as the new communications paradigms are, do we also > have a situation now developing where it might eventually become > very difficult or even impossible to ensure out-of-band lines of > communications remain available? > That's

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Joe Greco
> Those of us who lived through the Morris worm fragmenting the Arpa/Milnet in > 1988 and things like major worm-induced outages remember what a hassle it was > to *really* restart the net. Calling up your upstream on the phone asking if > it > was safe to turn up the link again, or looking for h

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 16:43:21 PDT, "andrew.wallace" said: > A British computer expert has been entrusted with part of a digital key, to > help > restart the internet in the event of a major catastrophe. You *do* realize this "news" is like two months old, right? http://www.icann.org/en/announce

Re: Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread Zaid Ali
Great! So I assume he is an elder of the Internet? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRmxXp62O8g On 7/27/10 4:43 PM, "andrew.wallace" wrote: > A British computer expert has been entrusted with part of a digital key, to > help > restart the internet in the event of a major catastrophe. > >   >

Web expert on his 'catastrophe' key for the internet

2010-07-27 Thread andrew.wallace
A British computer expert has been entrusted with part of a digital key, to help restart the internet in the event of a major catastrophe.   Paul Kane talked to Eddie Mair on Radio 4's PM programme about what he might be called upon to do in the event of an international online emergency.   ht