Re: : sudo & wheel group

2007-09-18 Thread Raimo Niskanen
On Mon, Sep 17, 2007 at 10:49:04AM -0400, Woodchuck wrote: > On Mon, 17 Sep 2007, Chris wrote: > > > On 9/17/07, Darrin Chandler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > problem is. This is why people keep asking you to explain the problem > > > more. > > > > Sorry for being vague. Ok, I have these in /e

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Keith Richardson
Chris wrote: I am finding that I need to add joeuser to use pkg_* tools, tcpdump as well. Is this the right way to do this? You might as well give joeuser root password if you give him access to pkg_add and pkg_delete tools. package framework has ability to run scripts as root. All joeus

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Woodchuck
On Sun, 16 Sep 2007, Matthew Szudzik wrote: > What's a laptop user to do? Run as root -- why not? Be careful. Limit PATH. Keep the cat off the keyboard. (This can be pesky if you're using vi at the time.) Open a root xterm, make the background some weird color, use a font and size you don't

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Aaron W. Hsu
Chris, Hrmm... Chris> Sorry for being vague. Ok, I have these in /etc/sudoers for joeuser. Chris> joeuser is also in the wheel group. [...] Chris> I am finding that I need to add joeuser to use pkg_* tools, tcpdump as Chris> well. Chris> Chris> Is this the right way to do this? Um, these are

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread James Hartley
On 9/17/07, Chris <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Ok, I have these in /etc/sudoers for joeuser. > joeuser is also in the wheel group. Why are you adding wheel group membership? Root access through sudo(8) does not require the user to be a member of wheel, but su(8) does. Jim

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Gilles Chehade
On Mon, Sep 17, 2007 at 09:52:06AM -0400, Matthew Szudzik wrote: > > If you're in operator, you can at least shutdown or reboot your system > > with /sbin/shutdown (which is setuid root and executable by those in > > operator). > > But (as I mentioned in the message), shutdown makes a very annoyin

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Woodchuck
On Mon, 17 Sep 2007, Chris wrote: > On 9/17/07, Darrin Chandler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > problem is. This is why people keep asking you to explain the problem > > more. > > Sorry for being vague. Ok, I have these in /etc/sudoers for joeuser. > joeuser is also in the wheel group. > > joeuse

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Stuart Henderson
On 2007/09/17 09:52, Matthew Szudzik wrote: > But (as I mentioned in the message), shutdown makes a very annoying beep. You might find this useful: $ grep bell /usr/src/etc/wsconsctl.conf #keyboard.bell.volume=0 # mute keyboard beep

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Matthew Szudzik
> If you're in operator, you can at least shutdown or reboot your system > with /sbin/shutdown (which is setuid root and executable by those in > operator). But (as I mentioned in the message), shutdown makes a very annoying beep. When shutting down the laptop in a hushed boardroom or lecture ha

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Paul de Weerd
On Sun, Sep 16, 2007 at 10:33:59PM -0400, Matthew Szudzik wrote: | /sbin/halt | Does anyone currently use the operator group for anything, or is it just a | historical vestige? Would there be anything wrong with giving the | operator enough hardware access to run the commands above? If you're

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Henning Brauer
* Matthew Szudzik <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [2007-09-17 04:41]: > Does anyone currently use the operator group for anything sure, taking dump(8)s -- Henning Brauer, [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] BS Web Services, http://bsws.de Full-Service ISP - Secure Hosting, Mail and DNS Services Dedicated S

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-17 Thread Chris
On 9/17/07, Darrin Chandler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > problem is. This is why people keep asking you to explain the problem > more. Sorry for being vague. Ok, I have these in /etc/sudoers for joeuser. joeuser is also in the wheel group. joeuser server = NOPASSWD: /sbin/mount, /usr/libexec/loca

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Clint Pachl
Matthew Szudzik wrote: The fact that you need to provide normal users with these kind of privileges indicates a possible flaw in your overall scheme. You may find that, after careful reconsideration, there are precious few commands that you would actually have to allow the users to run with su

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Antoine Jacoutot
On Sun, 16 Sep 2007, Matthew Szudzik wrote: Does anyone currently use the operator group for anything, or is it just a I do, for backups. -- Antoine

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Matthew Szudzik
> The fact that you need to provide normal users with these kind of > privileges indicates a possible flaw in your overall scheme. You may > find that, after careful reconsideration, there are precious few > commands that you would actually have to allow the users to run with > superuser privil

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Tobias Weingartner
Ted Unangst wrote: > > cp /bin/sh /usr/local/bin/xsh > chmod u+s /usr/local/bin/xsh > > then only tell the trusted users about xsh, > and you can avoid sudo altogether. Ohhh... EEEVVVILLL... :) -- [100~Plax]sb16i0A2172656B63616820636420726568746F6E61207473754A[dZ1!=b]salax

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Ted Unangst
On 9/16/07, Chris <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > So what's the "ideal" way to do things? Adding joeuser in the wheel > group and then add - joeuser ALL=(ALL) ALL in sudoers? And when the > joeuser account gets cracked, the cracker would be able to run > privileged commands? cp /bin/sh /usr/local/b

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Aaron W. Hsu
Chris, Thanks for the message... Chris> So what's the "ideal" way to do things? Of course, the ``ideal'' way to do anything really depends on what you want to do. It would help if you could give us some more details about what you are trying to do on the grand scheme of things, so that we coul

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Darrin Chandler
On Sun, Sep 16, 2007 at 05:14:30PM +1000, Chris wrote: > So what's the "ideal" way to do things? Ok, here's the scoop... there is NO single best way. There are lots of ways to solve these kinds of problems, and "ideal" changes with what the problem is. This is why people keep asking you to explain

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Rob
On 9/16/07, Chris <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > So what's the "ideal" way to do things? Adding joeuser in the wheel > group and then add - joeuser ALL=(ALL) ALL in sudoers? And when the > joeuser account gets cracked, the cracker would be able to run > privileged commands? That defies the whole p

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Lars Noodén
Chris wrote: > ... > user server = NOPASSWD: /sbin/mount, /usr/libexec/locate.updatedb I might suggest using groups rather than individual users in sudoers. On the small scale both are about the same, but using groups scales better (both time and quantity). So the above could be for the group ej

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Alexander Hall
Chris wrote: On 9/16/07, Aaron W. Hsu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: What exactly are you trying to enable users to do? The fact that you need to provide normal users with these kind of privileges indicates a possible flaw in your overall scheme. You may find that, after careful reconsideration, the

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-16 Thread Chris
On 9/16/07, Aaron W. Hsu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > What exactly are you trying to enable users to do? The fact that you need to > provide normal users with these kind of privileges indicates a possible flaw > in your overall scheme. You may find that, after careful reconsideration, > there are p

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-15 Thread Nick Guenther
On 9/15/07, Chris <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I been looking for ways to let normal user run privileged commands and > after some searching found that adding users to the wheel group is bad > and also adding NOPASSWD and ALL = ALL to sudoers for an user is also > plain as bad. The only alternative

Re: sudo & wheel group

2007-09-15 Thread Aaron W. Hsu
What exactly are you trying to enable users to do? The fact that you need to provide normal users with these kind of privileges indicates a possible flaw in your overall scheme. You may find that, after careful reconsideration, there are precious few commands that you would actually have to allo