Re: FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-06 Thread Girish Venkatachalam
On 18:04:48 Apr 06, Joel Knight wrote: > > It sounds like a race condition, where the server FIN reaches the proxy > > before the final data is sent out to the client. I'd have to dig into > > it a bit more. > > That's exactly what I saw when I broke out the sniffer to troubleshoot > this. > Ho

Re: FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-06 Thread Joel Knight
--- Quoting Camiel Dobbelaar on 2008/04/02 at 17:32 +0200: > Michael Hoffrath wrote: > > Same problem here Running OpenBSD 4.2 (GENERIC) #375 i386. > > > > It seems not only being a problem of Microsoft, I've found that problem also > > on VSFTPd (centos) and Filezilla (Windows 2003 Server). >

Re: FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-03 Thread Michael Hoffrath
>>"For passive mode data connections, ftpd will listen to a random high TCP >>port. The interval of ports used are configurable using sysctl(8) vari- >>ables net.inet.ip.porthifirst and net.inet.ip.porthilast." I'm aware of this, but we are running many different kinds of FTP-Servers and partiall

Re: FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-02 Thread Matt Hildebrand
> Yes it unfortunately causes real problems but forr now we are working > without ftp-proxy and therefore allowing all ports >1024. A little, ugly > workaround ;). In case it's helpful, it's perhaps worth mentioning that allowing a much more restricted range of ports, controlled by sysctls, is

Re: FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-02 Thread Michael Hoffrath
>>It sounds like a race condition, where the server FIN reaches the >>proxy before the final data is sent out to the client. I'd have to >>dig into it a bit more. >> >>Does it cause a real problem? (in other words: how urgent is the >>fix?) >> Yes it unfortunately causes real problems but for

Re: FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-02 Thread Camiel Dobbelaar
Michael Hoffrath wrote: > Same problem here Running OpenBSD 4.2 (GENERIC) #375 i386. > > It seems not only being a problem of Microsoft, I've found that problem also > on VSFTPd (centos) and Filezilla (Windows 2003 Server). > > Both are sending "221 Goodbye" but ftp-proxy seems to swallow that

Re: FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-02 Thread Michael Hoffrath
Hello, Same problem here Running OpenBSD 4.2 (GENERIC) #375 i386. It seems not only being a problem of Microsoft, I've found that problem also on VSFTPd (centos) and Filezilla (Windows 2003 Server). Both are sending "221 Goodbye" but ftp-proxy seems to swallow that from time to time. Regards

FTP-Proxy swallows 221 Message (MS FTP-Service)

2008-04-02 Thread smartTERRA NOC
Hello, I'm running 4.2 GENERIC#642 i386 and uses pf and ftp-proxy for a firewall service. I noticed that ftp connections, established with the help of ftp-proxy, don't receive the "221 Goodbye" Message from the FTP-Server. #:~ falk$ telnet 192.168.30.22 21 Trying 192.168.30.22... Connecte