Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot - Workaround

2005-10-08 Thread Jason Dixon
On Oct 8, 2005, at 6:59 PM, Tim wrote: I found my own workaround for this problem and I'm posting it on the chance it will help someone else. I did some more experimenting and tried adding more backup carp interfaces to the physical interface that already had three. When I did this, I not

Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot - Workaround

2005-10-08 Thread Tim
Tim timdarby.net> writes: > > I'm using CARP under 3.7 release version on two boxes that aren't firewalls, so > no pfsync involved and CARP configured as described in the FAQ. What I'm seeing > is that the box I've designated as BACKUP always boots with carp0 as INIT and > carp1 and carp2 both c

Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot - PROBLEM IDENTIFIED

2005-10-07 Thread Jason Dixon
On Oct 8, 2005, at 12:49 AM, Tim wrote: Sorry, I wasn't clear in my post. I meant to say "3 or more interfaces created as backup". I can add as many master carp interfaces as I want and it seems to be fine. Try adding a 3rd backup carp to one of your physical interfaces and let me know w

Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot - PROBLEM IDENTIFIED

2005-10-07 Thread Jason Dixon
On Oct 8, 2005, at 12:18 AM, Tim wrote: After some experimentation, it turns out that if I create 3 or more carp interfaces on the same physical interface, then carp0 always comes up as INIT on boot. I have replicated this on two other machines, so this is not just a fluke. Wrong. Here

Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot - PROBLEM IDENTIFIED

2005-10-07 Thread Tim
Tim timdarby.net> writes: > > I'm using CARP under 3.7 release version on two boxes that aren't firewalls, so > no pfsync involved and CARP configured as described in the FAQ. What I'm seeing > is that the box I've designated as BACKUP always boots with carp0 as INIT and After some experime

Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot

2005-10-07 Thread Michael Shalayeff
Making, drinking tea and reading an opus magnum from Tim: > William Bloom eldocomp.com> writes: > > > > > If I'd had this experience, I'd be tempted to use tcpdump on whichever > physical > > interface is carpdev for the suspect carp interface in order to verify that > > multicast is enabled

Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot

2005-10-07 Thread Tim
William Bloom eldocomp.com> writes: > > If I'd had this experience, I'd be tempted to use tcpdump on whichever physical > interface is carpdev for the suspect carp interface in order to verify that > multicast is enabled on your switch. With carp interfaces up, you should see > periodic mu

Re: CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot

2005-10-07 Thread William Bloom
If I'd had this experience, I'd be tempted to use tcpdump on whichever physical interface is carpdev for the suspect carp interface in order to verify that multicast is enabled on your switch. With carp interfaces up, you should see periodic multicast messages. If you don't see any, then you'v

CARP interface incorrectly comes up as INIT on boot

2005-10-07 Thread Tim
I'm using CARP under 3.7 release version on two boxes that aren't firewalls, so no pfsync involved and CARP configured as described in the FAQ. What I'm seeing is that the box I've designated as BACKUP always boots with carp0 as INIT and carp1 and carp2 both come up BACKUP as expected. The other