Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-19 Thread Kirill A . Korinsky
On Wed, 07 Aug 2024 01:38:05 +0200, David Uhden Collado wrote: > > > Generally I would expect somebody who is new to OpenBSD to do a scratch > > install on a spare machine to try out the system, but then re-install at > > least once rather than continue using that scratch system as their 'final'

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-13 Thread Karsten Pedersen
> Sent: Monday, August 12, 2024 at 8:17 PM > From: "Otto Moerbeek" > > It's also possible to tweak the auto partitioned proposal when > installing. Choose the appropriate option ((E)dit auto layout) and use > the R command to resize the partition sizes you don't like. Or just D to start from scra

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-12 Thread Otto Moerbeek
On Wed, Aug 07, 2024 at 01:50:39AM +0200, David Uhden Collado wrote: > > The rationale is that the installer is not able to make a reasonable > > guess about > > how you plan to use the system.  It knows the minimum required filesystem > > sizes, and if you have a moderate amount of extra disk it

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-09 Thread David Uhden Collado
Is it you that will do all these extra tests? I would like to contribute to the best of my abilities. However, it is evident that any improvement requires effort. If I possessed the necessary knowledge, I would implement these changes myself and propose them on the tech@ mailing list, just as

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-08 Thread Geoff Steckel
On 8/8/24 02:39, Eric Furman wrote: On Wed, Aug 7, 2024, at 8:44 PM, Justin Yates Fletcher wrote: On Wed, 2024-08-07 at 01:50 +0200, David Uhden Collado wrote: Now I understand the rationale. It might be beneficial for the installer to offer multiple templates when selecting the automatic pa

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-07 Thread Eric Furman
On Wed, Aug 7, 2024, at 8:44 PM, Justin Yates Fletcher wrote: > On Wed, 2024-08-07 at 01:50 +0200, David Uhden Collado wrote: >> >> >> Now I understand the rationale. It might be beneficial for the >> installer >> to offer multiple templates when selecting the automatic partitioning >> option. T

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-07 Thread Janne Johansson
> Now I understand the rationale. It might be beneficial for the installer > to offer multiple templates when selecting the automatic partitioning > option. These templates could cater to various common use cases, making This sounds like "lots more testing needs to be done for each release, for ea

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-07 Thread Justin Yates Fletcher
On Wed, 2024-08-07 at 01:50 +0200, David Uhden Collado wrote: > > > Now I understand the rationale. It might be beneficial for the > installer > to offer multiple templates when selecting the automatic partitioning > option. These templates could cater to various common use cases, > making > th

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-06 Thread David Uhden Collado
The rationale is that the installer is not able to make a reasonable guess about how you plan to use the system.  It knows the minimum required filesystem sizes, and if you have a moderate amount of extra disk it has rules on how to allocate the extra. But if you have an extremely large amount o

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-06 Thread David Uhden Collado
Generally I would expect somebody who is new to OpenBSD to do a scratch install on a spare machine to try out the system, but then re-install at least once rather than continue using that scratch system as their 'final' installation. For nothing else, because generally people fiddle with all sort

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-05 Thread Kenneth Gober
On Sun, Aug 4, 2024 at 6:24 PM David Uhden Collado wrote: > I would like to understand the rationale behind this design choice. Is > there a specific reason why the automatic partitioning is limited to > around 350GB for system partitions? Any insights or explanations you can > provide would be g

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-05 Thread Nick Holland
On 8/4/24 15:16, David Uhden Collado wrote: Hello, I have observed that the automatic partitioning feature of disklabel(8) does not allocate more than approximately 350GB to system partitions [1]. In my opinion, the tool should have been designed to use all available space on the storage device

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-04 Thread Crystal Kolipe
On Mon, Aug 05, 2024 at 03:42:48AM +0200, David Uhden Collado wrote: > > Why not just use a custom disklabel template that suits your needs? This > is the -t option to /sbin/disklabel. > > How is it possible to use a custom template from the OpenBSD installer? You'll need to drop to the shell and

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-04 Thread David Uhden Collado
> Why not just use a custom disklabel template that suits your needs? This is the -t option to /sbin/disklabel. How is it possible to use a custom template from the OpenBSD installer? On the other hand, this workaround is not the most convenient since one typically does not reinstall OpenBSD f

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-04 Thread Greg Thomas
I don't know if I'm misreading your inquiry but if I have more than enough storage space why would I allocate way too much space to system partitions by allocating it proportionally? On Sun, Aug 4, 2024 at 12:18 PM David Uhden Collado wrote: > Hello, > > I have observed that the automatic partit

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-04 Thread Åke Nordin
On 2024-08-04 21:16, David Uhden Collado wrote: > Hello, > I have observed that the automatic partitioning feature of disklabel(8) > does not allocate more than approximately 350GB to system partitions > [1]. In my opinion, the tool should have been designed to use all > available space on the

Re: Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-04 Thread Crystal Kolipe
On Sun, Aug 04, 2024 at 09:16:52PM +0200, David Uhden Collado wrote: > To address this limitation, I had to > write a custom program that calculates partition sizes to maintain their > initial proportions while occupying the entire storage device. Why not just use a custom disklabel template that

Automatic Disk Partitioning

2024-08-04 Thread David Uhden Collado
Hello, I have observed that the automatic partitioning feature of disklabel(8) does not allocate more than approximately 350GB to system partitions [1]. In my opinion, the tool should have been designed to use all available space on the storage device when partitioning. To address this limita