On Sun, Aug 4, 2024 at 6:24 PM David Uhden Collado <da...@uhden.dev> wrote:

> I would like to understand the rationale behind this design choice. Is
> there a specific reason why the automatic partitioning is limited to
> around 350GB for system partitions? Any insights or explanations you can
> provide would be greatly appreciated.
>

The rationale is that the installer is not able to make a reasonable guess
about
how you plan to use the system.  It knows the minimum required filesystem
sizes, and if you have a moderate amount of extra disk it has rules on how
to allocate the extra.

But if you have an extremely large amount of extra space there's no way to
tell what you have planned for it.  Are you going to run a database? Maybe
the extra space should go into /var.  Or better yet, use that extra space to
make a new filesystem like /var/mariadb or /var/postgresql.  Or maybe you
are setting up a web server and you'll want /var/www enlarged.  Maybe you
will want the extra space in an entirely new directory like /nfs.

If the installer can't reasonably guess, it is better to leave the space
unused
as it's easy to add space somewhere if you have extra, but hard if you
don't.
The idea here is to start with sane defaults, not immediately paint you into
a corner.

-ken

Reply via email to