Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Norbert Bollow
On 26 Mar 2017 00:20:17 - "John Levine" wrote: > Of course. But the fraction of domains registered by natural people > is quite low. And, of course, the claim that you need your own second > level domain to communicate on the Internet is ridiculous. Depends on the time horizon. If I want

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Dave Warren
On Sun, Mar 26, 2017, at 13:03, Norbert Bollow wrote: > On 26 Mar 2017 00:20:17 - > "John Levine" wrote: > > > Of course. But the fraction of domains registered by natural people > > is quite low. And, of course, the claim that you need your own second > > level domain to communicate on the

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread John Levine
In article <20170326220333.3c517c48@quill> you write: >If I want to be able to give people information for being able to >contact me via the Internet, so that I can have a reasonable expectation >of being able to make sure that this will still work in 20 years >(provided I am then still alive and h

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Dave Warren
On Fri, Mar 24, 2017, at 13:34, Neil Schwartzman wrote: > *PLEASE JOIN THE ICANN GROUP* and help us fight back against people > who are fighting *in favour* of crime. Please also take the time to understand that your needs are not my needs. I would be in favour of a WHOIS system that doesn't exp

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Dave Warren
On Sun, Mar 26, 2017, at 13:58, John Levine wrote: > In article <20170326220333.3c517c48@quill> you write: > >If I want to be able to give people information for being able to > >contact me via the Internet, so that I can have a reasonable expectation > >of being able to make sure that this will st

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Doug Barton
On 03/26/2017 01:58 PM, John Levine wrote: But I can't help noticing that people keep trying to change the topic. Not changing the topic, refuting your statement that no one needs their own domain name to communicate on the Internet. Once again, nobody* has a problem with privacy protection

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Rob McEwen, invaluement.com
John Levine said: "The problem is that the pro-crime crowd keep demanding that all the rest be anonymous or effectively anonymous, too." Exactly! Also, like some who are arguing against Neil Sw. on this, I too consider myself to be a very strong privacy advocate too. However what we currently ha

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Norbert Bollow
On 26 Mar 2017 20:58:50 - "John Levine" wrote: > In article <20170326220333.3c517c48@quill> you write: > >If I want to be able to give people information for being able to > >contact me via the Internet, so that I can have a reasonable > >expectation of being able to make sure that this will

Re: [mailop] LOUDMOUTHS WANTED!! ICANN WHOIS Replacement Work URGENT IMPORTANT ACTION NEEDED

2017-03-26 Thread Suresh Ramasubramanian
I have a hotmail account that I opened in 2000 And yes, I do see the childish style of argument that you mention. --srs > On 27-Mar-2017, at 2:28 AM, John Levine wrote: > > But I can't help noticing that people keep trying to change the topic. > Once again, nobody* has a problem with privacy