Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-27 Thread Jacques Menu
Le 28 sept. 2021 à 07:53, Ivanov Dmitry a écrit :What kind of programmed scores handling are you aiming at?Standard piano score with 2 staves and 4 voices: 2 voices per staff.OK, but you mentioned reading/manipulating music with programs, or did I get it wrong?Stangely enough, op

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-27 Thread Ivanov Dmitry
What kind of programmed scores handling are you aiming at? Standard piano score with 2 staves and 4 voices: 2 voices per staff. signature.asc Description: PGP signature

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-27 Thread Jacques Menu
Hello Dmitry, It looks like you’re struggling with the tools instead of going ahead using them. What kind of programmed scores handling are you aiming at? There are various ways, such as python-ly (https://pypi.org/project/python-ly/), ABC notation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ABC_notation)

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-27 Thread Thomas Morley
Am Mo., 27. Sept. 2021 um 17:05 Uhr schrieb Ivanov Dmitry : > > Something is not right. I installed lilypond 2.23.3 and processed > hello2.xml. I still have an incorrect result. > > Here is what I do and what I get: > > $ musicxml2ly ./hello2.xml > musicxml2ly: Reading MusicXML from ./hello2.xml ..

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-27 Thread Ivanov Dmitry
Something is not right. I installed lilypond 2.23.3 and processed hello2.xml. I still have an incorrect result. Here is what I do and what I get: $ musicxml2ly ./hello2.xml musicxml2ly: Reading MusicXML from ./hello2.xml ... musicxml2ly: Converting to LilyPond expressions... musicxml2ly: warni

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-27 Thread Jacques Menu
Hello Dmitry, xml2ly and MuseScore handle hello2.xml alright : the problem you have can be reproduced here with musicxml2ly (2.23.0-1) here. JM > Le 27 sept. 2021 à 10:46, Ivanov Dmitry a écrit : > > I can't reproduce your results. I tried to put your XML into hello2.xml and > compile it. Bu

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-27 Thread Ivanov Dmitry
I can't reproduce your results. I tried to put your XML into hello2.xml and compile it. But it produced pdf with the same error, Your lilypond file is compiling correctly for me. Can you try my xml? Is anything wrong with it? My lilypond version is 2.22.1. http://www.musicxml.org/dtds/partwise.dtd

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-25 Thread Paul Hodges
I'm not the person of whom the question was asked, but I have myself just been asked about MusicXML export. I am retired, with time on my hands, and have for some time used LilyPond to prepare music editions for the choir I sing in - so I am fluent with it for "straightforward" choral music wit

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-25 Thread Thomas Morley
Am Sa., 25. Sept. 2021 um 16:24 Uhr schrieb Jean Abou Samra : > > Hi Harm, > > Le 24/09/2021 à 22:52, Thomas Morley a écrit : > > I was tempted to offer a very high bounty to get a working xml-export. > > Alas, we already have > > https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/665 and the there > >

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-25 Thread Jean Abou Samra
Hi Harm, Le 24/09/2021 à 22:52, Thomas Morley a écrit : I was tempted to offer a very high bounty to get a working xml-export. Alas, we already have https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/665 and the there offered bounties are not that low ... Out of curiosity, what would be your own us

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Ivanov Dmitry
Jacques Menu: Dmitry, how do you generate MusicXML data? I do it manually. signature.asc Description: PGP signature

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Carl Sorensen
On 9/24/21, 3:52 PM, "Lukas-Fabian Moser" wrote: > I was tempted to offer a very high bounty to get a working xml-export. > Alas, we already have > https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/665 and the there > offered bounties are not that low ... One thing I

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Lukas-Fabian Moser
I was tempted to offer a very high bounty to get a working xml-export. Alas, we already have https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/665 and the there offered bounties are not that low ... One thing I noted while skimming through that issue and the linked conversations: There were stat

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Carl Sorensen
On 9/24/21, 2:52 PM, "Thomas Morley" wrote: Am Fr., 24. Sept. 2021 um 22:33 Uhr schrieb Carl Sorensen : > > We have automatic tests for xml2ly that check compliance with the musicXML standard. > > I'm fairly certain it's a problem with your musicXML, rather than xml2ly.

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Thomas Morley
Am Fr., 24. Sept. 2021 um 22:33 Uhr schrieb Carl Sorensen : > > We have automatic tests for xml2ly that check compliance with the musicXML > standard. > > I'm fairly certain it's a problem with your musicXML, rather than xml2ly. > > Unfortunately, I'm not expert enough on musicXML to find the mist

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Carl Sorensen
On 9/24/21, 2:37 PM, "Ivanov Dmitry" wrote: On 21-09-24 20:33:05, Carl Sorensen wrote: >Why are your writing your own musicXML and then using xml2ly, instead of just writing in lilypond? I am writing software for harmonization and XML is a better language for computers to

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Ivanov Dmitry
On 21-09-24 20:33:05, Carl Sorensen wrote: Why are your writing your own musicXML and then using xml2ly, instead of just writing in lilypond? I am writing software for harmonization and XML is a better language for computers to read then lilypond. signature.asc Description: PGP signature

Re: musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Carl Sorensen
We have automatic tests for xml2ly that check compliance with the musicXML standard. I'm fairly certain it's a problem with your musicXML, rather than xml2ly. Unfortunately, I'm not expert enough on musicXML to find the mistakes. Why are your writing your own musicXML and then using xml2ly, ins

musicXML: 2 staves, piano

2021-09-24 Thread Ivanov Dmitry
I was experimenting with a simple musicXML for a stadard piano score with 2 staves. I attached the sample file. Everything seems to be fine, but after I run musicxml2ly ./hello1.xml lilypond ./hello1.ly I get incorrect result. Is it musicxml2ly working incorrectly? hello1.xml Description: XML