Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-03-02 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Simon, > you can quote lyrics perfectly well. It’s just that of course the quoting > logic is based on durations, so I think explicit durations are unavoidable Ah! That makes sense. Despite the extra work, it’s probably QUITE worth it in my larger projects. Thanks! Kieren. __

Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-03-01 Thread Simon Albrecht
Hi Kieren, On 29.02.24 15:42, Kieren MacMillan wrote: I didn’t see an issue/request for quoting lyrics, so I added one (https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/6700) and we’ll see how the discussion goes. :) I was curious and tried, and in fact you can quote lyrics perfectly well. It

Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-03-01 Thread David Kastrup
Simon Albrecht writes: > The downside of that is that I cannot add more tags to those groups on > the fly, and always have to add them directly to the library file.) Suggestions for a user interface to do that? -- David Kastrup

Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-03-01 Thread Simon Albrecht
On 29.02.24 15:42, Kieren MacMillan wrote: use both \keepWithTag_and_ \removeWithTag like this: text = \lyricmode { \tag A { on -- ly al -- to } \tag nA { ev’ -- ry -- one ex -- cept al -- to } } #mindblown Why didn’t I think of using set theory?! THANK YOU! That hint a

Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-03-01 Thread Simon Albrecht
Hi David, On 29.02.24 15:54, David Kastrup wrote: I'd rather use \tagGroup alto,non-alto \lyricmode { \tag alto { on -- ly al -- to } \tag non-alto { ev’ -- ry -- one ex -- cept al -- to } } \keepWithTag alto ... \keepWithTag non-alto ... But one would need to look at the rest to see w

Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-02-29 Thread David Kastrup
Simon Albrecht writes: > This could be preferable if you can delineate the sections > well. Trying out \partcombine quickly made me avoid it until > absolutely necessary, but maybe it becomes manageable with clever and > experienced use of \partCombineApart and friends. In choral pieces, I > ofte

Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-02-29 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Simon, > huge respect for the kind of projects you are doing :) Thanks — I need all the [psychological] help I can get! LOL > Answering these questions is difficult because they can depend a lot on the > specifics of the music and any solution can become cumbersome because of only > a litt

Re: extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-02-29 Thread Simon Albrecht
Hi Kieren, huge respect for the kind of projects you are doing :) Answering these questions is difficult because they can depend a lot on the specifics of the music and any solution can become cumbersome because of only a little instance that doesn’t fit the schematic. A few thoughts: On 27

extracting a single “vocal line” (including lyrics) from multiple variables

2024-02-27 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi all, So… In the musical I’m currently co-writing (and solo-engraving!), I’ve got a bunch of different variables for the various vocal lines, e.g. Frogs_Sammy_notes = { … } Frogs_Sammy_lyrics = \lyricmode { … } Frogs_Michael_notes = { … } Frogs_Michael_lyrics = \lyricmode { … } Frogs_chorus_up