Re: lilypond-user Digest, Vol 65, Issue 34

2008-04-09 Thread Karl Hammar
Till: > Trevor Daniels schrieb: ... > > .3 Baroque rhythmic notation (new) > Karl: > > We don't have lilypond examples of this. I have seen this in a Novello > score for Purcells Dido. So I suggest we drop this for the moment. > (Though an ossia section might show what the editor want.) > >

Re: lilypond-user Digest, Vol 65, Issue 34

2008-04-09 Thread Graham Percival
On Wed, 09 Apr 2008 18:47:58 +0300 Till Rettig <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Actually Graham has pronounced that we should not have a > task-orientated structure, but just tell about the issues not > referring to the context they are used to. But maybe it is still ok > in this case. Ancient music

Re: lilypond-user Digest, Vol 65, Issue 34

2008-04-09 Thread Till Rettig
Trevor Daniels schrieb: OK, draft 8 will say: .6 Editorial markings .1 Annotational accidentals (was Musica ficta accidentals) (2.8.4) .2 Ligature brackets (was Ligatures) (2.8.2.4) .3 Baroque rhythmic notation (new) Karl: We don't have lilypond examples of this

Re: lilypond-user Digest, Vol 65, Issue 34

2008-04-09 Thread Till Rettig
Trevor Daniels schrieb: OK, draft 8 will say: .6 Editorial markings .1 Annotational accidentals (was Musica ficta accidentals) (2.8.4) .2 Ligature brackets (was Ligatures) (2.8.2.4) .3 Baroque rhythmic notation (new) (new - KH) Ok, so as I understand in 8.

Re: lilypond-user Digest, Vol 65, Issue 34

2008-04-09 Thread Karl Hammar
Trevor: ... > OK, draft 8 will say: > >.6 Editorial markings > .1 Annotational accidentals (was Musica ficta accidentals) > (2.8.4) > .2 Ligature brackets (was Ligatures) > (2.8.2.4) I don't regard ligature brackets as an editorial thing, since it is just the modern

Re: lilypond-user Digest, Vol 65, Issue 34

2008-04-09 Thread Trevor Daniels
Till Rettig wrote I don't know, what these slurs mean, I came up with the following editiorial items: 1. annotational accidentals 2. ligature brackets [I think they should be here, and not together with the ligatures] 3. Barock rhythm indication 1 is the same as 6.1, maybe 2 is the same as 6.

Re: lilypond-user Digest, Vol 65, Issue 34

2008-04-08 Thread Till Rettig
Hi Karl Hammar wrote Trevor Daniels wrote Karl Hammar wrote Till: 8.5 Transcription of ancient music Why not call it "Editing" or "Making an edition", but transcription is also fine. I think we'll stick with "Transcription" - it seems closer to th