Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Anton
Pierre-Jean: > My user opinion is that letting a postprocessor > change the structure of a document is confusing. I > don't like pdfroff for this reason. In my humble > opinion, writing the table of content in the > begining of a document is a job for a troff macro. But this would requ

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Ralph Corderoy
Hi Anton, > But this would require the somewhat non-standard way of using troff in > two passes. Is it non-standard? I thought the normal way was to set up two passes, or more strictly a loop until everything settles down into place, as this is how TeX does it too IIRC. Not that TeX's way of do

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Werner LEMBERG
>> My user opinion is that letting a postprocessor change the >> structure of a document is confusing. I don't like pdfroff for >> this reason. In my humble opinion, writing the table of content in >> the begining of a document is a job for a troff macro. > > But this would require the somewhat

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Mike Bianchi
Fair warning. This started as a short "I agree" note, but ... On Fri, Jul 29, 2011 at 04:12:40PM +0200, Werner LEMBERG wrote: > >> My user opinion is that letting a postprocessor change the > >> structure of a document is confusing. I don't like pdfroff for > >> this reason. In my humble opini

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> As a *roff user since the mid-1970s I am all too aware that to be > good at this you have to know and _understand_ a lot of details > about the document models (as represented by the different macro > collections: man, mm, mom, ms ...) and the fundamental commands, > registers, etc. To do even

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Mike Bianchi
On Fri, Jul 29, 2011 at 05:37:41PM +0200, Werner LEMBERG wrote: > : > > The other day I was thinking of creating, as a first step, a set of > > overlay macros for things like groff_mm (my macro package of choice) > > to ease the burden of learning and understanding it: > > > > .mm_Abs

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Peter Schaffter
On Fri, Jul 29, 2011, Mike Bianchi wrote: > I worry that *roff is an old technology loved only by old people. > It won't survive much longer if it isn't loved by people much > younger than me. ... > That way one would not have to memorize quite as much trivial > detail to understand the document s

[Groff] A trap with 'tbl'!

2011-07-29 Thread Ted Harding
Greetings All! I'm writing to flag up a little trap that one might fall into when using 'tbl'. Background: I'm setting up a table and I want each row to have a row number to the left of the table. So I have defined a "left margin number" string \*[lmn] to do that for each row. My first setup was

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Pierre-Jean
Mike Bianchi wrote: > What is missing is a Front Door that leads you gently into the Castle, teaches > you the way through the rooms, closets and pantries, so you can live > comfortably there with what is present. Then (and only then) should you be > led > down into the basement and shown how t

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Anton Shepelev
Ralph Corderoy: > Is it non-standard? I thought the normal way was > to set up two passes, or more strictly a loop > until everything settles down into place, as this > is how TeX does it too IIRC. Not that TeX's way > of doing anything necessarily makes it right. ;-) I meant, non-s

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Anton Shepelev
Mike Bianchi: > [...] To do even the simplest document requires > much-too-much expertise for the rank beginner. > > What is missing is a Front Door that leads you > gently into the Castle, teaches you the way > through the rooms, closets and pantries, so you > can live comforta

Re: [Groff] A trap with 'tbl'!

2011-07-29 Thread Deri James
On Friday 29 Jul 2011 22:25:59 Ted Harding wrote: > Greetings All! > I'm writing to flag up a little trap that one might > fall into when using 'tbl'. > > Background: I'm setting up a table and I want each > row to have a row number to the left of the table. > > So I have defined a "left margin n

Re: [Groff] gropdf and pdfroff

2011-07-29 Thread Clarke Echols
On 07/29/2011 06:10 PM, Anton Shepelev wrote: Mike Bianchi: [...] To do even the simplest document requires much-too-much expertise for the rank beginner. What is missing is a Front Door that leads you gently into the Castle, teaches you the way through the rooms, closets and pa

Re: [Groff] A trap with 'tbl'!

2011-07-29 Thread Heinz-Jürgen Oertel
Am Samstag 30 Juli 2011 schrieb Deri James: > I think this could be because tbl needs to know the max width of each column > before starting to output, so when considering the first column it will have > to > examine the width of \*[lmn] foreach row that you use it on. So these six > accesses