Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-09-14 Thread David G. Pickett via gnucash-user
Sometimes GnuCash and web sites round my stock shares to 2 places, TD Ameritrade and most do 3 places, for dividend reinvestment or mutual funds, but Schwab now does 4 places, so I have a mix of 3 and 4 places to reconcile to! The durable truth is that they take $x.yz and buy a.bcde or a.bcd sha

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-09-13 Thread John Ralls
You can always replace the DRIP prices by retrieving online quotes after creating the transactions. You could also edit or delete the DRIP transaction prices in the price DB; it won’t have any effect on the transactions. Regards, John Ralls > On Sep 13, 2024, at 08:26, R Losey wrote: > > What

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-09-13 Thread R Losey
What Derek said. Plus, the key important thing is that the number of shares and the money you actually spent are correct; these days (at least in the US), the brokerage is keeping track of correct prices. I run into this with reinvested dividends, if the dividend amount is small and the stock pri

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-09-13 Thread Derek Atkins
The answer is "no". And your Broker is lying to you. There is no such thing as $0.0036 so there is no "value" there. You should record the 4.000 shares and total value of $105.95 Ignore the "price" difference. It doesn't matter in the long run. Even if you are worried about the price basis, y

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-09-13 Thread NS
Thanks for the answers. There is a difference when I look at GNU Cash and my broker, albeit small, is there. I was just wondering if there was a way to set it up differently. On Mon, Aug 26, 2024 at 8:38 PM NS wrote: > First, let me tell you I am a recent user of GNUCash, and by no means I am >

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-08-27 Thread Kalpesh Patel
ay want to check the 'Fraction Traded' setting through the security setup settings (Tools --> Security Editor --> [select security] --> Edit). -Original Message- From: NS Sent: Monday, August 26, 2024 8:38 PM To: gnucash-user@gnucash.org Subject: [GNC] Rounding issues wi

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-08-27 Thread Kalpesh Patel
Original Message- From: NS Sent: Monday, August 26, 2024 8:38 PM To: gnucash-user@gnucash.org Subject: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock First, let me tell you I am a recent user of GNUCash, and by no means I am a bookkeeper or know a lot about accounting. I am using the tool to keep control of

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-08-27 Thread R Losey
On Mon, Aug 26, 2024 at 7:38 PM NS wrote: > First, let me tell you I am a recent user of GNUCash, and by no means I am > a bookkeeper or know a lot about accounting. > I am using the tool to keep control of some stock I own. > > Here is my issue. > I have a DRIP on the stock. My broker says the r

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-08-26 Thread John Ralls
The issue here is rounding. GnuCash enforces a minimum fraction on all commodities. For most currencies that fraction is 1/100; a few, e.g. Japanese Yen, it’s 1/1. Most mutual funds have a minimum fraction of 1/1000, most stocks have fractions of 1/—though DRIP accounts will pretend to have frac

Re: [GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-08-26 Thread Derek Atkins
GnuCash only maintains the number of shares and the total value. The per-share price is /always/ computed. When you are entering a transaction, GnuCash allows you to enter any two values and it will compute the third -- however it still only stores # shares and total value. IANAA, but IMHO you s

[GNC] Rounding issues with Stock

2024-08-26 Thread NS
First, let me tell you I am a recent user of GNUCash, and by no means I am a bookkeeper or know a lot about accounting. I am using the tool to keep control of some stock I own. Here is my issue. I have a DRIP on the stock. My broker says the reinvested price of each share was $26.4884, and they bo