Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-27 Thread Rodent of Unusual Size
Davanum Srinivas wrote: > > For the recordWS-PMC is willing to accept the project after its successful > incubation. in that case i think we're all set, the incubator can (and does) accept wsrp4j (ygh! that name! :-), and sam ruby, as the project's shepherd, can see about getting the mailin

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-04 Thread Richard Jacob
Ted Leung wrote: > What is the exact licensing of pluto.jar? It's not a *single* pluto.jar. The JARs pluto generates are the portlet API JAR and the reference impl. container JARs. We are currently working on the licence. In general we want to provide it royalty-free, as-is, redistributable, etc.

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-04 Thread Richard Jacob
Steven Noels wrote: > Out of curiosity: what's the specific problem with pluto.jar? Who is > still discussing stuff with lawyers (IIUC)? That's me. The problem is that wsrp4j usese pluto *JARs* which contain the portlet API classes and the JSR168 reference impl. container. The code for these is n

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Steven Noels
On 1/08/2003 19:09 Davanum Srinivas wrote: - There's Portlet API jar (named pluto.jar) that is required by both Charon and Jetspeed-2. The Jetspeed-2 folks are working on it (http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=jetspeed-dev&m=105949774325419&w=2). Questions: - Is availability of pluto.jar file a Sho

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Ted Leung
On 8/1/2003 10:09 AM, Davanum Srinivas wrote: Status update: - Started the VOTE on WS-PMC. Will report back the results. - There's Portlet API jar (named pluto.jar) that is required by both Charon and Jetspeed-2. The Jetspeed-2 folks are working on it (http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=jetspeed-dev&

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Richard Jacob
dims wrote: >#1 - The code for wsrp4j that we will get will have everything needed for WSRP4J to work in a >Tomcat/Servlet Container...Right? right >#2 - Later the JSR 168 reference impl may/can be extracted into a separate project...Right? yes, it will be the pluto project. Currently there is no

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Greg Stein
On Fri, Aug 01, 2003 at 05:52:17AM -0700, Davanum Srinivas wrote: > #1 - "-1 on the apparent process on how this "arrived"". Where EXACTLY is this > process > documented ("how/when should someone send a note to incubator about a > project to get the > ball rolling") I was referring to t

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Davanum Srinivas
Richard, Bottom-line: #1 - The code for wsrp4j that we will get will have everything needed for WSRP4J to work in a Tomcat/Servlet Container...Right? #2 - Later the JSR 168 reference impl may/can be extracted into a separate project...Right? Thanks, dims --- Richard Jacob <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Greg Stein
On Fri, Aug 01, 2003 at 11:55:13AM -0400, Rodent of Unusual Size wrote: > Greg Stein wrote: >... > > I'm also a -1 on the apparent process on how this "arrived" at the > > Incubator. > > miscommunication, is all. i assumed from what i was told that > everything was done and the actual incubation

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Richard Jacob
first off all sorry if I break the thread, but I subscibed a few minutes ago. Let me try to bring light into the wsrp4j proposal confusion: We intend to donate two projects: pluto and wsrp4j (formally named charon). pluto is the JSR168 (Portlet spec) reference implementation, wrsp4j is the implemen

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Davanum Srinivas
Status update: - Started the VOTE on WS-PMC. Will report back the results. - There's Portlet API jar (named pluto.jar) that is required by both Charon and Jetspeed-2. The Jetspeed-2 folks are working on it (http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=jetspeed-dev&m=105949774325419&w=2). Questions: - Is avai

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Rodent of Unusual Size
Greg Stein wrote: > > So how exactly was this projected "accepted"? I see zero discussion before > Ken's post to [EMAIL PROTECTED] That seems *very* inappropriate. it hasn't been accepted, at least not by the incubator. oh, you mean the sponsoring project. all i can say is what i was told by sa

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Davanum Srinivas
#1 - "-1 on the apparent process on how this "arrived"". Where EXACTLY is this process documented ("how/when should someone send a note to incubator about a project to get the ball rolling") #2 - I was a bit surprised that this note about Charon to incubator did not come from either me

RE: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-08-01 Thread Carsten Ziegeler
Davanum Srinivas wrote: > > FYI, AFAIK Charon depends on JSR168 Impl - jetspeed2 (code > checked in just a few days ago - > http://cvs.apache.org/viewcvs/jakarta-jetspeed-2/). So we should > not have a problem. > I thought the JSR 168 Impl is the Pluto proposal (http://nagoya.apache.org/wiki/ap

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-07-31 Thread Greg Stein
On Thu, Jul 31, 2003 at 07:06:13PM -0400, Rodent of Unusual Size wrote: > Ted Leung wrote: > > I'm unclear as to the project destination here. Your message says its > > WS and the proposal > > says Jakarta. I just looked and couldn't find it. I also couldn't find > > it in [EMAIL PROTECTED] A

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-07-31 Thread Davanum Srinivas
Ted, Ken, The dependent project was the JSR168 Impl which is Jetspeed2 (already in our CVS). There's no other dependencies that i know of. Ted, Yes, we've not voted on it yet in the WS-PMC. I will start the VOTE and get the results back to incubator folks. Thanks, dims --- Ted Leung <[EMAIL P

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-07-31 Thread Rodent of Unusual Size
Ted Leung wrote: > > I'm unclear as to the project destination here. Your message says its > WS and the proposal > says Jakarta. I just looked and couldn't find it. I also couldn't find > it in [EMAIL PROTECTED] > As long has voted to accept it, I've no problem. It's just that I'm on > th

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-07-31 Thread Davanum Srinivas
FYI, AFAIK Charon depends on JSR168 Impl - jetspeed2 (code checked in just a few days ago - http://cvs.apache.org/viewcvs/jakarta-jetspeed-2/). So we should not have a problem. Thanks, dims --- Rodent of Unusual Size <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > ibm has a codebase that they want to open through

Re: request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-07-31 Thread Ted Leung
On 7/31/2003 2:30 PM, Rodent of Unusual Size wrote: they are ready to dot the eyes and cross the teas; they are assembling the clas, will be executing the software grant as soon as i get it to them, they have a community of developers, they have a sponsoring asf project (web services) which is eag

request to accept new project: wsrp4j

2003-07-31 Thread Rodent of Unusual Size
ibm has a codebase that they want to open through the asf. the detailed proposal has already been posted on the apache wiki at http://nagoya.apache.org/wiki/apachewiki.cgi?CharonProposal by sam, several months ago. they are ready to dot the eyes and cross the teas; they are assembling the clas, w