Re: [PROPOSAL] Proposing Giraph for the Apache Incubator

2011-07-15 Thread Phillip Rhodes
On Fri, Jul 15, 2011 at 2:14 PM, Avery Ching wrote: > Hi, > > Here is a link to the proposal in our GitHub wiki: > > https://github.com/aching/Giraph/wiki/Apache-Incubator-Proposal > > Should the contents of this proposal to be copied to the incubator section of the ASF wiki, at something like:

Re: [PROPOSAL] Proposing Giraph for the Apache Incubator

2011-07-15 Thread Phillip Rhodes
On Fri, Jul 15, 2011 at 2:14 PM, Avery Ching wrote: > Hi, > > I would like to propose Giraph as an Apache Incubator project. Giraph is a > large-scale graph processing infrastructure (inspired by Pregel) that runs > entirely on Hadoop. Giraph applications and MapReduce jobs coexist on > shared

Re: [PROPOSAL] Proposing Giraph for the Apache Incubator

2011-07-15 Thread Edward J. Yoon
Based on that statement, I expect that if Giraph is accepted in the Apache Incubator, our projects will hopefully be able to share ideas and grow together. +1 Sent from my iPhone On 2011. 7. 16., at 오후 12:55, Avery Ching wrote: > > Based on that statement, I expect that if Giraph is accepte

Re: [PROPOSAL] Proposing Giraph for the Apache Incubator

2011-07-15 Thread Avery Ching
Ed, Offline, you and I have discussed potential future collaboration in our projects. However, there are significant differences in our approaches today. * Hama has been focused on BSP computing. It only recently (June 30 - about 16 days ago) opened a JIRA for graph processing (https://issue

Re: [PROPOSAL] Proposing Giraph for the Apache Incubator

2011-07-15 Thread Edward J. Yoon
Just FYI, My heavy concern is that the boundaries between 'Apache Hama' and 'Giraph' you said, can be collapsed in near future. * Someone already contributed Pregel-like vertex API set on top of Hama v0.2[1]. * The Hama job will be run on both Hama own cluster and Hadoop nextGen. Then, BSP-bas

[PROPOSAL] Proposing Giraph for the Apache Incubator

2011-07-15 Thread Avery Ching
Hi, I would like to propose Giraph as an Apache Incubator project. Giraph is a large-scale graph processing infrastructure (inspired by Pregel) that runs entirely on Hadoop. Giraph applications and MapReduce jobs coexist on shared Hadoop instances and Giraph applications can be part of Oozie