Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-08 Thread Roman Neuhauser
# [EMAIL PROTECTED] / 2005-06-06 10:25:51 -0300: > several linux distros have achieved a difficult goal: ease of > installation-use combined with a stable system. (...) I think that > there are a lot of linux distros out there that are really easy to > use, and even more "friendly" or "beatiful" th

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-07 Thread Ronald Klop
Did you guys already unmount your filesystem? On Mon, 06 Jun 2005 17:48:26 +0200, Oliver Fromme <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Yuval Levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Oliver Fromme wrote: > > I do look carefully every day, because it's my job. I work > > with various operating systems every

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread jonathan michaels
On Mon, Jun 06, 2005 at 10:25:51AM -0300, Maxi Combina wrote: snipped for brevity > combined with a stable system. I have no trouble with a "diffucult / > unix-like" OS, but a lot of people do. And this a _fact_.They dont > have time to spend learning to use a "dificult" OS. And I think that > if

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Matthias Buelow
Iulian M wrote: > http://www.parashift.com/c++-faq-lite/big-picture.html#faq-6.5 > > it's about the best programing language ... but if you replace "programing > language" with "OS" it still applys. >From the web page: "Anyone who argues in favor of one language over another in a purely tech

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Iulian M
On Monday 06 June 2005 17:02, Oliver Fromme wrote: > > Yup, I know the usual freebsd-for-servers and linux-for- > desktops arguments. And to be honest, I'm fed up with > them. They're lies. I'm running FreeBSD on my desktop > at home, a lot of people are happily running Linux on > their servers

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Oliver Fromme
Yuval Levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Oliver Fromme wrote: > > I do look carefully every day, because it's my job. I work > > with various operating systems every day, including FreeBSD > > and Linux. > > From a professional I would expect a more mature and balanced approach, > rather

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Wilko Bulte
Can the two of you please take this bikeshed to -chat or wherever? Thank you, Wilko On Mon, Jun 06, 2005 at 11:00:41AM -0400, Yuval Levy wrote.. > Oliver Fromme wrote: > > >I do look carefully every day, because it's my job. I work > >with various operating systems every day, including FreeBSD

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Yuval Levy
Oliver Fromme wrote: I do look carefully every day, because it's my job. I work with various operating systems every day, including FreeBSD and Linux. From a professional I would expect a more mature and balanced approach, rather than "my favorite OS is the best one and the others have no

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Oliver Fromme
Maxi Combina <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > I do not seed the need of insult other OS. > May be you need to look more carefully. I am not talking _only_ about > this thread. You replied specifically to my mail, and you didn't mention any other threads. > > Well, I don't see any. But ev

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Matthias Buelow
Maxi Combina wrote: > companies, etc) to move to an open source OS, we must do an effort. I > think that there are a lot of linux distros out there that are really > easy to use, and even more "friendly" or "beatiful" than windows. > I dont think that FreeBSD has achieved this. I dont think there

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Maxi Combina
> > I do not seed the need of insult other OS. May be you need to look more carefully. I am not talking _only_ about this thread. As I said, I dont wanna flame, just reflecting (or trying to :) ) > > Even worse if the other OS is open source (as linux). > > Being open source doesn't mean that a

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-06 Thread Oliver Fromme
Maxi Combina <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Personally, I have used the ext2fs driver for exactly one > > reason: to migrate data from Linux to FreeBSD on machines > > which are being converted from the Dark Side. And that > > I do not seed the need of insult other OS. And I do not see

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-04 Thread Matthias Buelow
Vulpes Velox wrote: > I have had the same problem with fat32 filesystems before also. I > have ut2004 installed on a fatpartition on my dualboot machine. To > make it accessible so that I can play it in freebsd aswell, I need to > mount and unmount the drive from a rc.d script under /usr/local/etc

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-04 Thread Vulpes Velox
On Thu, 02 Jun 2005 15:21:01 +0200 Matthias Buelow <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Maxi Combina wrote: > > Hello, I am running freebsd 5.4, and every time I reboot, I get a > > mesasge when the kernel is mounting the filesystems. It says that > > the fs were not properly unmounted, and must chek them

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted [OT]

2005-06-03 Thread Maxi Combina
> Personally, I have used the ext2fs driver for exactly one > reason: to migrate data from Linux to FreeBSD on machines > which are being converted from the Dark Side. And that I do not seed the need of insult other OS. Even worse if the other OS is open source (as linux). With this attitude we

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-03 Thread Oliver Fromme
yuval levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > In my opinion, an O/S that can not handle the most > popular file systems is handicapped in a world of > increasing diversity. Please excuse me jumping in here, but ext2/ext3 is certainly _not_ one of the most popular file systems for most members of this

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Matthias Buelow
Don Lewis wrote: > That might help to an extent, but would not eliminate the problem. Any > file systems between root and the mount point of the ext2 file system > would be busy and would not be able to be unmounted. They would still > be marked dirty and would need to be fsck'ed after the reboo

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Don Lewis
On 3 Jun, Matthias Buelow wrote: > Don Lewis wrote: > >> Nope, the ext2fs problem is different. It is caused by ext2fs holding >> persistent references to disk buffers that causes the kernel shutdown >> code to to think that not all the dirty buffers have been written to >> disk and skip unmount

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Matthias Buelow
Don Lewis wrote: > Nope, the ext2fs problem is different. It is caused by ext2fs holding > persistent references to disk buffers that causes the kernel shutdown > code to to think that not all the dirty buffers have been written to > disk and skip unmounting all the file systems. Can't that be c

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread yuval levy
--- Dick Davies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > * yuval levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [0656 21:56]: > > --- Dick Davies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: > > > How would you feel if your car dealer would tell > you > > that the car is just fine, you only have to > remember, > > every time before you start it,

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Don Lewis
On 2 Jun, Charles Swiger wrote: > On Jun 2, 2005, at 4:56 PM, yuval levy wrote: >>> If it's a pain to remeber, maybe try sticking >>> something in rc.shutdown? >> >> Thank you for trying to help, but I do not find this >> reply helpful. That's a quick and dirty fix, not a >> solution. > [ ...car a

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Dick Davies
* yuval levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [0656 21:56]: > --- Dick Davies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > How would you feel if your car dealer would tell you > that the car is just fine, you only have to remember, > every time before you start it, to chew a gum and > stick the chewing gum on that little hole

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Matthias Buelow
yuval levy wrote: > Anyway, I am just trying to stirr some talk and get > some attention to an issue which I find important. > Maybe somebody with the appropriate skills will read > this and fix the issue. Noone complains that people stir things up every now and then.. at least then the developer

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Charles Swiger
On Jun 2, 2005, at 4:56 PM, yuval levy wrote: If it's a pain to remeber, maybe try sticking something in rc.shutdown? Thank you for trying to help, but I do not find this reply helpful. That's a quick and dirty fix, not a solution. [ ...car analogy snipped... ] Quick and dirty fixes are ok fo

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread yuval levy
--- "J. T. Farmer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > yuval levy wrote: > > >--- Dick Davies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: > > > >>* Yuval Levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [0647 15:47]: > >> > >> > >>>Is it possible to fix this issue? from the > >>> > >>> > >>description it seems to me > >> > >>

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread J. T. Farmer
yuval levy wrote: --- Dick Davies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: * Yuval Levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [0647 15:47]: Is it possible to fix this issue? from the description it seems to me that the issue got worse since freebsd 5.3 (assuming Maxi's root partition is ufs2

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread yuval levy
--- Dick Davies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > * Yuval Levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [0647 15:47]: > > > > > Is it possible to fix this issue? from the > description it seems to me > > that the issue got worse since freebsd 5.3 > (assuming Maxi's root > > partition is ufs2). > > If it's a pain to reme

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Dick Davies
* Yuval Levy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [0647 15:47]: > > > Is it possible to fix this issue? from the description it seems to me > that the issue got worse since freebsd 5.3 (assuming Maxi's root > partition is ufs2). If it's a pain to remeber, maybe try sticking something in rc.shutdown? -- 'Ugh,

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Yuval Levy
Matthias Buelow wrote: Maxi Combina wrote: Hello, I am running freebsd 5.4, and every time I reboot, I get a mesasge when the kernel is mounting the filesystems. It says that the fs were not properly unmounted, and must chek them. Them main concern is with my root partition. I also have en e

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Ronald Klop
On Thu, 02 Jun 2005 15:09:08 +0200, Maxi Combina <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hello, I am running freebsd 5.4, and every time I reboot, I get a mesasge when the kernel is mounting the filesystems. It says that the fs were not properly unmounted, and must chek them. Them main concern is with my r

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Matthias Buelow
Maxi Combina wrote: > Hello, I am running freebsd 5.4, and every time I reboot, I get a > mesasge when the kernel is mounting the filesystems. It says that the > fs were not properly unmounted, and must chek them. Them main concern > is with my root partition. I also have en ext3 partition (which I

Re: filesystems not properly unmounted

2005-06-02 Thread Steven Hartland
Are you 100% sure u didn't use "shutdown -p" as I've seen this happen and its apparently due to IDE disks lying about when they have flushed all data to disk. Steve - Original Message - From: "Maxi Combina" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Hello, I am running freebsd 5.4, and every time I reboo