Re[2]: problem analysys (Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.)

2011-02-21 Thread Andrey Smagin
I think problem may be like there http://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-net/2010-April/025156.html what type of IFace for your FWD rules ? I have crash only for ng IF. over gif fwd work without problem. But it only for my case. Mon, 21 Feb 2011 00:13:12 +0100 письмо от Pawel Tyll : > >

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-20 Thread Peter Jeremy
On 2011-Feb-20 01:39:00 +0100, Pawel Tyll wrote: >Since nobody came up with any interest in having this properly >investigated, then I suppose I'm the only one that uses dummynet for >some larger-scale traffic shaping - maybe that's my mistake? I'm using dummpnet+pf (not ipfw) on (roughly) FreeBS

Re: problem analysys (Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.)

2011-02-20 Thread Pawel Tyll
> addresses not needed, thanks. From what i saw in the backtrace, the panic > occurred on an incoming packet on the 'antispoof' option. > The ruleset confirms the backtrace, but since > 'antispoof' happens > to be run on every packet given it is on the first rule, > it apparently has nothing to do

Re: problem analysys (Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.)

2011-02-20 Thread Luigi Rizzo
On Mon, Feb 21, 2011 at 12:13:12AM +0100, Pawel Tyll wrote: > > understood. I am just saying that for instance the vlan presence and > > changes is quite significant in this context. > > You say vlans are "pretty much static" but can you tell us who adds/remove > > them, assign addresses ? > It's

Re: problem analysys (Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.)

2011-02-20 Thread Pawel Tyll
> understood. I am just saying that for instance the vlan presence and > changes is quite significant in this context. > You say vlans are "pretty much static" but can you tell us who adds/remove > them, assign addresses ? It's not that much work and changes are simple and far between. I do that p

Re: problem analysys (Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.)

2011-02-20 Thread Luigi Rizzo
On Sun, Feb 20, 2011 at 11:50:28PM +0100, Pawel Tyll wrote: ... > This machine is only doing dummynet traffic shaping from significant > things (otherwise it runs a dhcpd, ntpd and named). It's pretty > straight-forward routing, packets come in, packets come out via static > routes - there are curr

Re: problem analysys (Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.)

2011-02-20 Thread Pawel Tyll
> The way a problem is presented has a big impact on how it gets handled: > in this specific case the poster is pointing out a possible culprit > (which may be helpful or misleading), and gives no hint on other > things that may be relevant: number of interfaces, vlans, tunnels, taps, > bpf etc ? a

problem analysys (Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.)

2011-02-20 Thread Luigi Rizzo
On Sun, Feb 20, 2011 at 04:54:34AM +0100, Pawel Tyll wrote: > > I've never seen a trace like this, and no absolutely nothing about > > dummynet, sorry. > > If it is in some way em's fault, then making sure you have the latest code > > would be > > a good idea. I have a test driver that is under s

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-19 Thread Pawel Tyll
> I've never seen a trace like this, and no absolutely nothing about dummynet, > sorry. > If it is in some way em's fault, then making sure you have the latest code > would be > a good idea. I have a test driver that is under selective test, it does > effect the code > path that you seem to be i

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-19 Thread Pawel Tyll
> I was actually going to suggest Pawl try a different network device if > possible. I'm using dummynet on a network gateway equipped with > on-board bge(4). I haven't had any crashes, but then again, I'm not > seeing that many packets either. It seems to be closely related to amount of processed p

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-19 Thread Pawel Tyll
> Same backtrace as reported here? I'm unable to get the new backtrace, but judging from what I can see on the console pre-reboot, it's exactly the same deal since 8.0-RELEASE - panic with dummynet as main star. > What revision of the em(4) driver code are you using? I know Jack has > been working

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-19 Thread Brandon Gooch
On Sat, Feb 19, 2011 at 8:40 PM, Jack Vogel wrote: > I've never seen a trace like this, and no absolutely nothing about dummynet, > sorry. > If it is in some way em's fault, then making sure you have the latest code > would be > a good idea. I have a test driver that is under selective test, it do

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-19 Thread Jack Vogel
I've never seen a trace like this, and no absolutely nothing about dummynet, sorry. If it is in some way em's fault, then making sure you have the latest code would be a good idea. I have a test driver that is under selective test, it does effect the code path that you seem to be in, so it might be

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-19 Thread Brandon Gooch
2011/2/19 Pawel Tyll : > Hi guys, lists, > > It's me, the bi-weekly panic guy. Guess what, it crashed today. As an > act of desperation I disabled the pipe dumping script after previous > crash, which today turned out to be merely a coincidence and didn't > prevent panics. (I thought it to be a lon

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-02-19 Thread Pawel Tyll
Hi guys, lists, It's me, the bi-weekly panic guy. Guess what, it crashed today. As an act of desperation I disabled the pipe dumping script after previous crash, which today turned out to be merely a coincidence and didn't prevent panics. (I thought it to be a longshot anyway, but it was the only

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-24 Thread Pawel Tyll
> Just replying so you know I'm seeing it, but something that takes 14 days to > even happen > is NOT going to be an easy one to find. As Brandon said, all the info you > can provide please. Here's the dump in case you've not seen it before. Somehow 8.1-RELEASE managed to make a proper dump, which

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-24 Thread Jack Vogel
Just replying so you know I'm seeing it, but something that takes 14 days to even happen is NOT going to be an easy one to find. As Brandon said, all the info you can provide please. Jack On Mon, Jan 24, 2011 at 9:11 AM, Brandon Gooch wrote: > On Sun, Jan 23, 2011 at 7:08 PM, Pawel Tyll wrote:

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-24 Thread Brandon Gooch
On Sun, Jan 23, 2011 at 7:08 PM, Pawel Tyll wrote: > On Fri, Jan 7, 2011, Brandon Gooch wrote: >> It's likely that the mbuf handling problem (in em_refresh_mbufs()) is >> triggered by the processing you're doing with ipfw (or elsewhere for >> that matter), so, yes, I think it's a bug fixed in the

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-23 Thread Pawel Tyll
On Fri, Jan 7, 2011, Brandon Gooch wrote: > It's likely that the mbuf handling problem (in em_refresh_mbufs()) is > triggered by the processing you're doing with ipfw (or elsewhere for > that matter), so, yes, I think it's a bug fixed in the revision > discussed. > When you update and test, pleas

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-07 Thread Brandon Gooch
On Fri, Jan 7, 2011 at 10:14 AM, Pawel Tyll wrote: > One more question tough, > > I have 4 identical machines, also with em-driven NICs - yet this is > the only one that dies like this. OTOH Other machines don't do traffic > shaping and do not use ipfw that extensively. Does this match your > theo

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-07 Thread Pawel Tyll
One more question tough, I have 4 identical machines, also with em-driven NICs - yet this is the only one that dies like this. OTOH Other machines don't do traffic shaping and do not use ipfw that extensively. Does this match your theory? ___ freebsd-n

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-07 Thread Pawel Tyll
Hi Brandon, > Might this be an issue with the em(4) driver? It may be that it's fixed: > http://svn.freebsd.org/viewvc/base?view=revision&sortby=date&revision=216440 Thanks Brandon - I'll update to fresh stable and get back to you... in three to four weeks :)

Re: [Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-06 Thread Brandon Gooch
2011/1/6 Pawel Tyll : > Hi lists, > > I've reported this problem: > http://www.freebsd.org/cgi/query-pr.cgi?pr=152360 > > and ever since 8.1-RELEASE this machine keeps panicking every two weeks > or so. Any help will be much appreciated. I'll be happy to provide any > more info to help tracking thi

[Panic] Dummynet/IPFW related recurring crash.

2011-01-06 Thread Pawel Tyll
Hi lists, I've reported this problem: http://www.freebsd.org/cgi/query-pr.cgi?pr=152360 and ever since 8.1-RELEASE this machine keeps panicking every two weeks or so. Any help will be much appreciated. I'll be happy to provide any more info to help tracking this down. __